|
Acton, California
Extradition International
January 24, 2000
Three inmates escaped from a private transport company when the private guards
stopped at a mini-mart and left the keys in the ignition. When the guards
weren’t looking, the inmates jumped in the front seat and the CA Highway
Patrol on a high-speed chase that ended in a crash. (Los Angeles Times, 1/24/00)
Baker
Community Correctional Facility
San Bernardino, California
Cornell
March 29, 2007 Contra Costa Times
A race-related fight broke out at a minimum-security community prison,
sending four inmates to the hospital with minor injuries, state prison officials
said. The fight at the Baker Community Correctional Facility in San Bernardino
County occurred at 7 p.m. Wednesday and lasted a few minutes, said Terry
Thornton, a spokeswoman for the California Department of Corrections. Twelve
black and white inmates started brawling in the yard of the all-male prison and
guards rushed to break up the melee. About 80 inmates were in the yard at the
time. Four inmates were taken to the hospital with minor bumps and bruises. The
cause of the fight was under investigation. "They started to fight. They were
told to stop and they did," Thornton said Thursday. The 12 inmates were later
transferred to state prisons, she said. Baker, with 250 inmates, is operated by
Cornell Companies Inc., which provide services to state governments on a
contract basis. The facility is 155 miles east of Los Angeles.
December 8, 2003
A prison riot that left 17 inmates injured at a private correctional facility in
the Mojave Desert may have been triggered by the arrival of a jailhouse
"snitch" just hours before, a transfer that countered normal safety
protocols, a prison official said Wednesday. A preliminary investigation
suggests the brawl between white inmates and Latino inmates, broke out after the
informant -- who was white -- was attacked in the prison yard, said Marvin Wiebe,
a senior vice president of Houston-based Cornell Companies Inc., which operates
the prison. The disturbance escalated into a riot because of a policy that
bars guards at privately owned prisons from using force to quell a violent
uprising, said Russ Heimerich, a spokesman for the California Department of
Corrections. Unlike guards at California's 33 state-run prisons, officers at the
private lockups are not permitted to carry weapons. Wiebe said that
typically an informant would not be sent to a private prison, which lacks
protective custody arrangements for such inmates.
(Los Angeles Times)
December 8, 2003
A prison riot that injured 16 inmates appeared to be sparked by racial tensions,
prison officials said Wednesday. The riot at Baker Community Correctional
Facility started around 8 p.m. Tuesday and involved between 30 and 60 white and
Hispanic inmates, said Terry Thornton, a spokeswoman for the state Department of
Corrections. She said initial reports of a fire in the prison were incorrect.
Four inmates were airlifted to hospitals and 12 were transported by ambulance
for treatment of stab wounds. All but four were released and taken to the
California Institution for Men in Chino. No guards were injured in the brawl.
About 270 inmates were in the prison at the time. Inmates used sharpened pieces
of metal and plastic and broom handles to assault each other, Thornton said. The
prison yard was secured at 10:30 p.m. Tuesday and the prisoners were locked
down. The 288-bed facility is run by the privately held Cornell Cos. of Houston
and handles minimum-security male offenders under contract with the California
Department of Corrections. Baker is about 160 miles east-northeast of downtown
Los Angeles. (AP)
December 4, 2003
Eighteen prisoners were injured when inmates rioted at Baker Community
Correctional Center on Tuesday night. About 100 inmates, many with weapons,
fought and set a small fire in a yard office while others escaped over the fence
of the privately operated prison. Law enforcement officers took back control at
10:30 p.m. Staff members of Cornell Corrections Inc., which operates the prison,
called 911 at 8:07 p.m. requesting assistance to break up fights between inmates
in the prison yard, according to San Bernardino County Sheriff's Department
dispatchers. Sheriff's deputies were called in from Baker, Barstow and Chino, as
well as a helicopter crew and officers from the California Highway Patrol,
according to sheriff's spokeswoman Cindy Beavers. Mutual-aid calls also went out
to fire protection services from Newberry Springs, Yermo, Fort Irwin, Adelanto
and the county. Five patients were airlifted to Las Vegas-area hospitals for
treatment and 13 others were taken by ambulance, said Tracey Martinez,
spokeswoman for the San Bernardino County Fire Department. All of the injured
were prisoners, most suffering stab wounds, she said. There were no immediate
reports of injuries to prison guards. Beavers said the low-security prison
didn't have armed guards for its 262 inmates. (Daily Press)
December 4, 2003
More than 100 inmates were involved in a riot at a private minimum-security
prison, injuring 17, officials said. A small fire was set inside a building.
The majority of victims suffered stab wounds, said Tracey Martinez, spokeswoman
for the San Bernardino County Fire Department. County fire spokesman Bret Raney
said 17 were injured overall, with five airlifted to hospitals for treatment and
the others taken by ambulance. There were no reports of injuries to guards
or other authorities who responded to the rioting shortly after 8 p.m. Tuesday.
The prison yard was secured at 10:30 p.m. and prisoners were locked down,
Martinez said. A small blaze was confined to a container in a guard's
shack. The 262-bed facility is run by the privately held Cornell
Companies, of Houston, one of the country's largest private prison operators.
The prison handles minimum-security male offenders under contract with the
California Department of Corrections. The facility, which opened in 1988,
has 52 buildings and was once a housing complex for Pacific Bell employees and
their families. Inmates at the minimum security prison have bolstered emergency
crews that respond to accidents along Interstate 15, the desert highway that is
the quickest route to Las Vegas from Southern California. Baker is a
small, rural community about 160 miles east-northeast of downtown Los Angeles.
(AP)
December 16, 2002
A local developer is
embroiled in what's now a class-action lawsuit that
claims hundreds of workers -- many from Bakersfield -- were grossly underpaid
during construction of a prison. An
attorney for the workers claims the Moreland Corporation failed to pay
prevailing wages as it was required to while building a $16 million prison in
San Bernardino County five years ago.
Prevailing
wages -- essentially union scale wage rates -- are substantially
higher than non-union wages. About
300 workers, the majority from Bakersfield, are owed an undetermined amount of
money and many don't even know it, said the plaintiff's attorney Richard Donahoo
of Santa Ana. The plaintiffs are
seeking back wages and damages. Terry
Moreland, chief executive officer of Moreland Corporation, said Donahoo has all
the facts wrong. The prison was not
a "public works" project that required prevailing wages to be paid and
he didn't know that was even a possibility until construction was almost
finished, Moreland said.
He
said Moreland Corporation built the prison on its own -- not under contract with
the state or with the state's guarantee it would pay to house inmates there as
it eventually did -- so there was no reason to pay prevailing wages.
Only one contract involving the prison exists between a Moreland entity
and the state and it had nothing to do with the prison's construction, he said.
Moreland said the California Department of Corrections contracted with
Maranatha Production Company simply to provide services at the prison. Moreland said while he owns a small percentage of Maranatha,
it is separate from Moreland Corporation. Donahoo claims they're one and the
same. At issue is construction of
the 500-bed, private Victor Valley Community Correctional Facility completed in
1998. Moreland Corporation was the general contractor; Moreland Family LLC was
the builder and owns it now. The
lawsuit claims Moreland knew through rulings by the state Department of
Industrial Relations and language in Maranatha's contract with the CDC that the
people building the prison must be paid prevailing wages. It also claims
Moreland withheld that information from subcontractors he hired and that workers
were paid as little as $5.25 an hour when they should have been paid more than
$25 per hour. (Bakersfield.com)
June 22, 2002
Embattled emergency response services on Interstate 15 between Newberry Springs
and state line may receive a major boost if the governor signs next year's
California budget. The plan calls for the prison in Baker to re-open in
August. The legislature and the governor's office have agreed to fund the
prison again, but the budget remains unsigned for other reasons, he said.
The Cornell Correctional Facility in Baker is one of five privately owned
community corrections facilities in California that closed near July 1 after
their contracts with the state expired. (The Desert Dispatch)
June 19, 2002
Closure of the minimum security prison in Baker at the end of this month comes
as a blow to the small community, but some consequences will be shared by the
entire county. Inmates and staff found out last November that the prison had
been dropped from the state budget for the Department of Corrections, prison
director Brick Tripp said. The last prisoner will be leaving Monday, and the
facility will shut down June 30, the final day of the contract between the state
department and the private prison. The owners of the facility are seeking
alternative tenants, including federal or county prisons, said Ron Baumgarten,
spokesman for Cornell Corrections. The Baker Community Correctional Facility is
one of five private prisons in California scheduled to close. State officials
decided to stop contracting with private entities to house prisoners because of
numerous problems with the system, said Youth and Adult Correctional Agency
Assistant Secretary Steven Green. He cited numerous lawsuits because of
improperly trained staff members and inmates not receiving all the programs they
are entitled to at the state s 16 private prisons as one reason for the decision
to close the prisons. “The contract prison exercise has been a complete
failure as far as we are concerned,? he said. (Privateer News)
June 19, 2002
Live Oak's Leo Chesney Center probably will survive the budget ax, says a state
official who Thursday blasted the facility's operator for its "sleazy"
public relations campaign. "It's looking much more like it's going to stay
open," said Stephen Green, assistant secretary in the Youth and Adult
Correctional Agency. "This isn't over until the budget is final. Certainly,
the indications are it's going to stay open." The tentative budget deal to
keep Chesney open was hammered out Wednesday. "Clearly, we're a little
better off today than we were two days ago with the decision made
(Wednesday)," said Marvin Wiebe, senior vice president of Cornell Companies
Inc., which runs the Chesney Center under a contract with the state. "The
legislators had some concerns about the lack of options for women to do their
time in Northern California and wanted to see as many options as possible remain
and indicated they were willing to fund that," Green said. "The
legislators had some concerns about the lack of options for women to do their
time in Northern California and wanted to see as many options as possible remain
and indicated they were willing to fund that," Green said. "When they
are willing to fund it, that makes it a lot easier for us."
"This was just one of just hundreds of government programs that were being
looked at to be scaled back or eliminated," Green said. "This one got
more attention because Cornell made some of the most outrageous lies imaginable
and went around the state accusing us of murder. They behaved in a most
unprofessional manner." Cornell "used the Enron playbook," Green
said, referring to the bankrupt energy trading company. "They're a
Houston-based company, a for-profit concern. They're very interested in
protecting their profits. They don't care who they have to malign to do
it." Green called Cornell's public relations campaign "sleazy. I don't
think it was slick. It bore no relationship to the truth ... "He said
there's a chance the state may put the contract out to bid or have the
Department of Corrections take over management. "We have an option on the
property and therefore control the property," Wiebe said. "The
expectation of the community is that Cornell would operate it as we have for the
last 13 years." If the state took over, it would cost an additional $1
million for salaries and benefits, he said. (Privateer News)
June 17, 2002
Setting up a potential showdown between lawmakers and Gov. Gray Davis, a
legislative budget committee voted Friday to keep open four private prisons the
governor had slated for closure. Davis had originally proposed shuttering five
prisons, but earlier this week agreed to keep open a women's minimum-security
facility. The budget conference committee does not have the final say, however.
The prisons will likely be a point of negotiation as the budget moves to the
full Assembly and Senate. And Davis can always veto the measure when the budget
hits his desk. The San Francisco Chronicle)
June 14, 2002
After a brief reprieve, legislative budget writers have voted to close two small
privately operated prisons in Kern County. They are among five minimum-security
community correctional facilities Gov. Gray Davis marked for elimination in his
proposed budget for the coming fiscal year. The Kern County installations are
the Mesa Verde facility in Bakersfield and another one in McFarland operated by
Wackenhut Corrections. The contracts for all five of the prisons run out June
30. Under an agreement with the governor, the budget committee voted late
Wednesday to keep open a women's correctional facility in Northern California
but to close the other four. Supporters of the prisons staged an aggressive
lobbying campaign to head off the closures. (Bakersfield.com)
June 12, 2002
Gov. Gray Davis, facing pressure from several lawmakers, reversed himself
partially and agreed to permit one of five private prisons to continue
operating, administration officials said Tuesday. At least two dozen women
legislators signed a letter last month urging that Davis keep open the Leo
Chesney Correctional Facility at Live Oak, north of Sacramento. Also in doubt is
whether the contractor, Cornell Co. of Houston, would continue operating the
facility, or whether the contract would be put up for competitive bidding. The
administration, trying to close a $24-billion budget deficit, had contended that
closing the five private prisons would save the state $2.8 million.
May 6, 2002
Cornell Corrections, a Houston company that owns two of the five private prisons
California is planning to close, took its fight to the airwaves this weekend.
The company has spent nearly $70,000 to produce and promote a 30-minute video on
the prison closures, which will shutter its facilities in Live Oak in Sutter
County and Baker in eastern San Bernardino County. This weekend, it paid $10,000
to television stations in Bakersfield, Fresno and Sacramento to air the video in
its entirety. Titled "Blood Money," the video accuses Gov. Gray Davis
of closing the prisons as a favor to the state prison guards union, which has
contributed heavily to Davis' election fund. (San Francisco Chronicle)
August 28, 2001
Autopsy planned in inmate's death Sheriff's homicide detectives are
investigating the death of an inmate Sunday at Baker Community Correctional
Facility, coroner's officials said Monday. Jamie Bengtson, 22, of Baker
was found dead in his bunk about 7 a.m., the San Bernardino County Coroner's
Department reported. The death was determined to be suspicious and the San
Bernardino County sheriff's homicide detail was called to investigate.
(The Press-Enterprise (Riverside, CA)
Border Patrol
Wackenhut (Group 4)
June 4, 2008 San Diego Union-Tribune
Two Border Patrol contract workers were arrested on suspicion of conspiring
to shuttle illegal immigrants from San Diego to Los Angeles for $2,500 apiece
instead of returning them to Mexico. Christopher Saint Lucero and Manley Lamont
Smith work for Wackenhut Corp., which holds a Border Patrol contract to escort
illegal immigrants to Mexico after they are captured by agents in California,
Arizona, New Mexico and Texas. According to court documents, Saint Lucero told a
colleague that he had been involved in about 10 smuggling attempts. The men were
arrested Sunday after Saint Lucero allegedly escorted a group of illegal
immigrants from the Border Patrol's Chula Vista station to the border in
Tijuana. According to a statement of probable cause, Mexican authorities refused
to admit two who identified themselves as Salvadorans. One was an undercover
agent. Authorities say Saint Lucero then brokered the deal to get the two men to
Los Angeles. Smith allegedly met them at the Border Patrol station in his
Wackenhut jeep and offered to hide them. Saint Lucero and Smith were expected to
make an initial court appearance today, said Debra Hartman, a spokeswoman for
the U.S. attorney's office in San Diego. The charge against them, conspiracy to
transport illegal immigrants, is a felony.
June 3, 2008 AP
A Border Patrol contractor says 2 of its employees have been arrested for
investigation of releasing illegal immigrants from federal custody. Wackenhut
Corp. says the employees were arrested Sunday in the San Diego area and are in
jail facing felony charges. For about two years, Wackenhut has held a contract
to return illegal immigrants to Mexico after they are captured by Border Patrol
agents. A senior vice president, Marc Shapiro, told The Associated Press Tuesday
that this is the first time Wackenhut employees have been arrested for allegedly
releasing immigrants. He said his company has returned more 1 million illegal
immigrants to Mexico. Shapiro declined to name the suspects. A Border Patrol
spokesman had no immediate comment.
California
City Corrections Center
California City, California
CCA
July 19, 2006 LA Daily News
A Tennessee-based company that operates a prison in California City is
starting environmental studies for an adjoining 550-bed prison in anticipation
of vying for a contract to house state inmates. Corrections Corporation of
America is starting environmental studies examining the impacts of a
200,000-square-foot prison. Citing sensitivity for a potential customer and the
competitive process, a CCA spokesman said it was too early to talk about costs
of such a facility or staffing. "The state issued a request for proposals to
build and operate a community correctional facility," said CCA spokesman Steve
Owen. "As part of our preliminary work, we are preparing the environmental
studies. It is still very preliminary to say what the state will ultimately
pursue."
January 13, 2003
With
29 years experience in corrections work for both the government and private
sector, Warden Percy Pitzer is looking forward to hanging his hat Monday in the
office of his own consulting company. Pitzer's
resignation as warden of the California City Correctional Center became
effective Friday, his last day at the prison he has stood watch over since June
2000. "I'm leaving on very good terms with (Corrections
Corporation of America)," Pitzer said. "I want to do something on my
own." On Monday, Warden
Charles Gilkey, recently retired from the Federal Bureau of Prisons, begins his
stint at the California City Correctional Center.
Also on Monday, Pitzer, who spent 25 years with the Federal Bureau of
Prisons and four years with CCA, officially opens Creative Corrections in Las
Vegas (email: createcorrection@aol.com). He plans to provide consulting services
with corrections departments throughout the West, and establish programs to
educate inmates and reduce the cost of incarceration. (The Bakersfield
Californian)
October 10, 2002
In a move hailed as historic by private prison giant Corrections Corporation of
America and representatives of the Mexican government, an agreement was signed
Monday to establish a Mexican high school program at the California City
Correctional Center. (Bakersfield California)
February 7, 2002
A 42-year-old inmate
at the California City Corrections Center was in
serious
condition Thursday evening at Kern Medical Center after suffering a stab
wound to his neck on Wednesday, officials said.
The private facility since September 2000 has operated on a federal
contract
for inmates, he said.
About 95
percent of its inmates are serving sentences for drug and
deportation crimes.
The
prison is operated by the Corrections Corporation of America, which is
based in Nashville, Tenn. (The Bakersfield Californian)
California
Department of Corrections
June 5, 2008 San Francisco Chronicle
Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger was within his rights to declare a state of emergency
at California's overcrowded prisons in 2006 and begin transferring inmates out
of state, an appeals court ruled Wednesday over the objections of the prison
guards union. The ruling by the state Third District Court of Appeal in
Sacramento overturned a judge's decision and was welcomed by Schwarzenegger, who
is separately defending the state against lawsuits by inmates seeking to reduce
the overall prison population and improve the prisons' health care system. A
federal judge has transferred control of prison health care in California to a
court-appointed manager after ruling that the system violated constitutional
standards. There are nearly 160,000 inmates in the 33 state prisons, which were
designed to hold about 83,000. The state is planning construction that will
expand the capacity of state prisons and county jails by 53,000. A referee
appointed by a federal court panel has proposed measures to reduce the prison
population by 27,000 over four years, to 133,000. The measures would include
alternatives to prison for some parole violators and felons facing short
sentences. Wednesday's ruling "comes at a critical juncture in our prison reform
efforts," Schwarzenegger said in a statement. "I am pleased that their decision
allows out-of-state transfers to continue while our comprehensive reforms to
reduce overcrowding are fully implemented." Laurie Hepler, a lawyer for the
prison guards' union and another prison employee union that challenged the
inmate transfers, said her clients disagreed with the ruling and would appeal to
the state Supreme Court. Schwarzenegger issued the order in October 2006 after a
special legislative session on prison overcrowding fizzled, with Democrats
seeking changes in sentencing laws and Republicans calling for prison expansion.
As the inmate population continued to climb, 16,000 prisoners occupied bunks in
prison gyms and other temporary quarters. Schwarzenegger has said as many as
8,000 inmates could be shipped out of state. So far, nearly 3,900 prisoners have
been transferred to out-of-state prisons run by private companies under
contracts with California. The transfers have continued despite a ruling in
April 2007 by a Sacramento County judge that Schwarzenegger had acted illegally.
Superior Court Judge Gail Ohanesian agreed with the unions that state law allows
a governor to issue an emergency order only when local officials need state help
in responding to a disaster, and that the use of private prison employees
violated civil service laws. The appeals court had put Ohanesian's ruling on
hold while the state appealed. In its ruling Wednesday, the court said the
governor can issue orders to respond to emergencies in state institutions that
may endanger residents. In this case, the court said, the lack of space in state
prisons was causing overcrowding in local jails, forcing counties to release
some inmates who might commit more crimes. Overcrowding also increased the risk
of diseases that could spread outside the prisons and had led to local water
pollution from sewage spills caused by overtaxed prison wastewater systems, the
court said. The court also said California's civil service rules allow the state
to employ private contractors when public employees are not available to meet
urgent needs. The planned expansion of state prisons will take years to
complete, and the prison system will need five years to eliminate staffing
shortages, the court said. "California cannot build or retrofit the prisons
needed overnight, no matter how much money it invests to solve the problem,"
Presiding Justice Arthur Scotland said in the 3-0 ruling. The only available
lockups are in other states and are staffed by private employees, he said.
August 18, 2007 Sacramento Bee
California corrections officials have begun sending hundreds of foreign national
inmates against their will to a private prison in Mississippi as part of a
stepped-up, out-of-state transfer plan. The first two flights of prisoners to
the Tallahatchie County Detention Facility in Tutwiler, Miss., have taken place
without incident, officials said, in spite of fears expressed by the California
correctional officers union that the forced transfers would be met with inmate
violence. "Many of the inmates had never been on a plane before in their lives,"
said Scott Kernan, the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation's
chief deputy secretary for adult operations. "They were a little scared. But
once they got on the flight, they were fine." Some 200 foreign national inmates,
mostly from Mexico, were shipped to the Mississippi prison on flights July 20
and July 27, a state prison spokesman said. A total of 597 inmates -- including
397 volunteers -- have now been sent to private prisons in Mississippi, Arizona
and Tennessee. Kernan said the state hopes to move 5,000 prisoners to
out-of-state institutions by June 30 to help relieve overcrowding in California.
"We have a very aggressive schedule that will include trips of approximately 120
inmates every couple of weeks," Kernan said. Some 173,000 inmates in the state
are being housed in space designed for about half that many, with federal judges
now considering a motion to place a population cap on the system that could
result in early releases for tens of thousands of prisoners. Francisco Estrada,
a lobbyist for the Mexican American Legal Defense and Education Fund, said the
transfers of the foreign nationals raise a host of potentially problematic legal
issues for the corrections agency. If the inmates are legal residents, the
transfers figure to separate them from their families and immigration attorneys,
and "that's wrong," Estrada said. They also create a prospect for racial
targeting on the part of prison officials. "We need to be very careful," Estrada
said, adding that he will be discussing the issue with Mexican American Legal
Defense and Education Fund attorneys. Foreign nationals being transferred under
the out-of-state program are all subject to holds "or potential holds" placed on
them by Immigration and Customs Enforcement, said corrections spokesman Bill
Sessa. They include both legal and illegal residents, he said. No inmates "with
demonstrated family ties" are being transferred for now, Sessa said. Nor are any
being moved "if they're in the middle of legal proceedings," including
immigration matters, Sessa said. The California Correctional Peace Officers
Association in February won a ruling in Sacramento Superior Court stopping the
transfer program. The union claimed the program violated state civil service
protections guaranteed under the California Constitution. The ruling has since
been stayed pending an appeal by Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger. CCPOA leaders also
voiced opposition to the transfers during the debate over the recently enacted
$7.9 billion prison construction plan, which included legislative approval for
moving 8,000 inmates out of state. Union officials said the involuntary
transfers would put officers in danger from resisting inmates. CCPOA spokesman
Ryan Sherman said Friday that the union is "very grateful" that no officers have
been injured in extracting the prisoners from their cells. "We're hopeful that
will continue as the governor continues to do these unconstitutional transfers,"
Sherman said. Sherman characterized the Tallahatchie County prison in
Mississippi, operated by the Correctional Corp. of America, as one of "the most
troubled" in the country. He based his assessment on newspaper articles
detailing assorted disturbances at the prison dating back to 2003. "Private
prisons lower the bar for the entire profession by providing extremely limited
training and remarkably poor compensation and benefits," Sherman said. "They're
in it to make a buck. Public safety is nowhere on their priority list." CCA
spokeswoman Louise Grant said her company "is extremely proud of the
Tallahatchie County Correctional Facility" and that private prisons are no more
dangerous than those operated by the state.
July 23, 2007 Fresno Bee
Two federal judges on Monday ordered creation of a special panel to
recommend ways to relieve California's overcrowded prisons, a move that could
lead to the capping of the inmate population or the early release of some
prisoners. In doing so, the judges rejected the main solution set forth by Gov.
Arnold Schwarzenegger and state lawmakers to address a crisis that has been
building for decades. Last spring, they agreed to an ambitious $7.8 billion
program to build 53,000 new prison and jail cells. The judges said that plan,
submitted to the courts in June, will only make matters worse for the California
Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation. The state can't hire enough guards
and medical professionals to provide proper care and oversight for the inmates
it has now, let alone the thousands more who might be added through the building
program. "From all that presently appears, new beds will not alleviate this
problem but will aggravate it," U.S. District Court Judge Lawrence Karlton of
Sacramento wrote. Schwarzenegger said he will appeal the judges' decision to
create the three-judge panel.
June 4. 2007 LA Times
Two appointees whom Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger sent to fix California's
dysfunctional prison healthcare system pushed a $26-million, no-bid contract for
outside medical services while contract reviewers steadfastly maintained it was
overpriced and illegal, records and interviews show. But instead of providing a
strong step toward reforming the California Department of Corrections and
Rehabilitation's $1.8-billion medical system, the handling of this relatively
small contract erupted into a fight that forced out the two appointees and
highlights what critics say are systemic contracting breakdowns that helped
bloat healthcare costs at the state's 33 prisons. The contract for a pilot
program at two Southern California prisons was supposed to be a model for
improving the care of inmates who need to see specialists — one of the major
failings that led a federal judge to seize control of prison healthcare and
appoint a receiver last year to oversee it. However, John Hagar, chief of staff
for receiver Robert Sillen, said, "This is a classic example of the department
looking at a problem and jumping to a solution that, in fact, does not work and
increases costs unnecessarily…. "It appears there were outside influences," he
said. "It was not being done at the urging of the contract staff who usually
negotiate the contract. They were saying 'No.' " After hiring a private prison
industry lobbyist, a Florida company successfully submitted a proposal for the
three-year pilot program. Although the contract was not finalized, corrections
officials last summer gave the company permission to start working and bill the
state. After finding out about the deal, Hagar swiftly froze the contract
process before Christmas and later halted payments. The appointees who arranged
the contract soon resigned. The state inspector general launched a
conflict-of-interest investigation of one who held stock in a company listed as
a subcontractor. And now the contractor wants the state to repay $2.6 million
for inmate medical expenses that company officials say they incurred. This ugly
contract dispute has been a distraction in the first year of a long-overdue
effort to improve inmate medical treatment, said Don Specter, director of the
Prison Law Office, a nonprofit whose lawsuit on behalf of the state's 175,000
prisoners prompted U.S. District Court Judge Thelton Henderson to take over
prison healthcare in 2005. The contract uproar centered on Medical Development
International, a $100 million-a-year business that arranges medical
appointments, handles billing, and contracts with doctors and hospitals to serve
inmates. It was founded in 1992 by a father and son, Richard and Ted Willich.
MDI has grown into one of the largest medical providers for the Federal Bureau
of Prisons, having won contracts at 27 facilities. That work led California
lawmakers to invite a company official to testify at a 2004 hearing into
skyrocketing prison healthcare costs in the state. About two years ago, MDI
officials hired Mark Nobili, a Sacramento lobbyist whose clients included a
private prison operator. To date, records show that MDI has paid Nobili at least
$170,000. MDI representatives learned that the point people for new prison
contracts were Peter Farber-Szekrenyi and Darc Keller — both longtime medical
administrators appointed by Schwarzenegger in late 2005 to help reform
healthcare. In March 2006, MDI submitted a proposal to deliver up to $26 million
in services at the state prisons in Tehachapi and Lancaster, where backlogs for
outside medical appointments were acute. Among the providers MDI listed was
Mobile Medical International Corp., which supplies surgical and diagnostic
facilities in big tractor-trailer trucks. Keller recently had served as a senior
vice president at Mobile Medical and, according to his economic interest
statement, he owned $10,000 to $100,000 in the company's stock. As MDI was
preparing its California proposal, company Vice President Ted Willich said he
learned that Keller once had worked at Mobile Medical, so he asked Keller to
call the firm because MDI was having trouble contacting it about potential work
on a federal contract. However, Willich denied that Keller encouraged MDI to use
Mobile Medical for the California pilot program. "To me, it is ridiculous," he
said of the inspector general's probe. "There is a whole lot of nothing there."
Keller said that, although he called Mobile Medical to help out MDI, he was
unaware that his former employer was being lined up as a subcontractor until
Mobile Medical later appeared in MDI's proposal. Keller said that he had moved
to liquidate his stock in Mobile Medical shortly after his appointment and that
the sale was completed Aug. 8 — a few weeks before MDI began work on the
project. "There is no conflict because there is no enrichment," he said. "No one
got money…. We never did have a [final] contract." Although MDI ultimately did
not use Mobile Medical, Keller's participation in the contracting process may
have violated the state Political Reform Act, said Robert Stern, president of
the Center for Governmental Studies in Los Angeles. "The violation could be that
he participated in a decision where he had a financial interest: the stock he
owned," Stern said. Violations are punishable by a fine or jail term. The state
Fair Political Practices Commission, which enforces the conflict-of-interest
law, would neither confirm nor deny that it was conducting an investigation. The
inspector general's office, an independent corrections oversight agency,
declined to comment. The MDI contract mess unfolded as the state controller
issued an audit report in early August outlining waste and abuse in medical
contracting at prisons. On Aug. 31, Farber-Szekrenyi requested issuance of a
$26-million contract to MDI, then the company began work. Farber-Szekrenyi "gave
us the green light," said Willich of MDI. "We were given assurances by Darc
[Keller] and Peter that we would be paid, and we were told to do the work." To
become final, the contract required approvals by contracting and legal staff at
corrections as well as attorneys at the state Department of General Services.
But interviews and corrections department e-mails reviewed by the receiver's
office show that contracting staff raised objections, such as whether the
contract should have been competitively bid, whether MDI needed a medical
license and whether the rates were too high. When MDI complained about the
delays, Hagar said, Farber-Szekrenyi and Keller repeatedly urged the employees
to move the contract ahead. "Nobody leaned on them to approve a contract; we
asked them the status of the contract," Farber-Szekrenyi said, adding that he
told the contractor to start work without a contract because there was an
emergency, with hundreds of medical appointments backlogged. Concerned about
delays with the contract last fall, Farber-Szekrenyi said he gave MDI and a
corrections attorney a couple of weeks to resolve the medical licensing issue —
and it was. Meanwhile, employees who process medical contracts were placed under
the receiver. A short time later, Hagar learned from one of them that Farber-Szekrenyi
and Keller were implementing a pilot program without competitive bidding — and
that contracting staff thought the price was exorbitant and that the work
required a medical license. Hagar stopped the contract and later asked the
inspector general to investigate. Although the receiver said he had been unaware
of the pilot program, Farber-Szekrenyi said he personally informed Sillen about
it. Farber-Szekrenyi and Keller said that earlier this year they were forced to
resign by the governor's office, which declined to comment. Though MDI said it
saved the state money and had dramatically reduced backlogs for appointments at
the two prisons, Hagar said his investigators found healthcare still in crisis
there. Tehachapi Warden Joe Sullivan, who served as interim warden at Lancaster
early this year, said MDI had inmates scheduled for appointments but they had
not all been seen by doctors. "In my view, they were doing an excellent job," he
said. The receiver's office now is developing its own contracts with providers.
And MDI is threatening to sue if necessary to recoup $2.6 million not reimbursed
by the state. MDI's Willich said the company apparently was caught in a fight
between two gubernatorial appointees and a powerful court-appointed receiver.
"We were the meat in the sandwich," he said.
June 2, 2007 Sacramento Bee
State corrections officials resumed transferring inmates to out-of-state
prisons Friday, moving 38 convicts by bus to Arizona. The transfers had been
placed on hold since November, when two public employee unions convinced a
Sacramento judge that sending inmates out of state violated California's civil
service laws. Superior Court Judge Gail Ohanesian's ruling has since been stayed
pending an appeal to the 3rd District Court of Appeal by the Schwarzenegger
administration. Oral arguments have yet to be scheduled. Corrections spokesman
Seth Unger said state officials "believe we have statutory authority" to go
ahead with more transfers, and he suggested that if the administration lost its
appeal, it would not pose a major problem. "We'll cross that bridge when we come
to it," Unger said. Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger obtained legislative approval in
the recently enacted Assembly Bill 900 prison construction and rehabilitation
package to transfer up to 8,000 inmates, involuntarily if it comes to that. Only
inmates volunteering for the out-of-state placement were transferred Friday,
however. The California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation is planning
to transfer as many as 400 inmates a month to help ease overcrowding, with
18,000 inmates now living in gyms, dayrooms and other spaces not designed to
house them. "Temporary out-of-state inmate transfers will provide immediate
relief to California's prison system while the rest of the governor's
comprehensive reforms are implemented," Corrections Secretary Jim Tilton said in
a prepared statement. Tilton said the transfers "will also give us breathing
room" to try to pick up the system's rehabilitation effort and also to help
improve its medical delivery system, which a San Francisco federal judge has
declared unconstitutional. Friday's transfers to the Florence Detention Center
in Arizona increased to 218 the number of California inmates being housed in the
prison, which is owned and operated by the Correctional Corporation of America.
Another 76 state prisoners have been transferred to the West Tennessee Detention
Facility, another CCA-owned prison not far from Memphis. The California
Correctional Peace Officers Association and Service Employees International
Union Local 1000 were the unions filing the suit last fall that temporarily
blocked the transfers. CCPOA spokesman Lance Corcoran said Friday that even
though the most recent transfers involved only inmates who the department said
wanted to go out of state, the decision to move out prisoners who don't want to
go "is absolutely one of the most dangerous things this administration has
utilized." Corcoran said the prison system has been "marketing these
(out-of-state) institutions much like cruise ships," yet still has fallen short
of obtaining anywhere near the 19,000 inmates the corrections agency initially
said were interested in the transfers. "Very quickly, they're going to have to
move them involuntarily, then we'll see what happens from there," Corcoran said.
Union leaders have said they expect inmates who don't want to be transferred out
of state to wage intense struggles to keep from being removed from their cells.
April 6, 2007 Sacramento Bee
The Schwarzenegger administration sought Thursday to block a court ruling
that the governor's program transferring inmates out of state is "unlawful." In
the meantime, the administration is taking the ruling by Sacramento Superior
Court Judge Gail Ohanesian to the state's 3rd District Court of Appeal.
Ohanesian ruled against the administration on Feb. 20, but the official order
blocking the order wasn't entered until Monday. The state filed its appeal on
Tuesday, and on Thursday filed the stay order on Ohanesian's ruling until the
appeal is heard. In a statement, Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger said his office is
prepared to "fight to preserve our emergency efforts to address the prison
overcrowding crisis." He said the out-of-state transfers, in which hundreds of
prisoners already have been moved to private prisons in Arizona and Tennessee,
are "imperative to relieve the pressure on our overburdened prison system and
improve safety for correctional officers, staff and inmates." Ohanesian's ruling
agreed with the California Correctional Peace Officers Association and Service
Employees International Union Local 1000 that the transfers violated the state's
civil service protection laws. Her ruling also said the governor overstepped his
authority by issuing an emergency proclamation on the prison overcrowding
because the issue remains within the state's ability to control. Moreover, the
judge's ruling said, no local authorities asked the state for assistance. The
challenge to the governor's authority to declare an emergency created "wider
implications" that his appeal will seek to address, Schwarzenegger said in his
statement. "It jeopardizes my executive authority to maintain the public's
safety, the lives and property of our citizens," Schwarzenegger said. " CCPOA
attorney Gregg Adam said the administration is setting itself up for potentially
larger problems if it goes ahead with the transfers. He said the California
Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation is just about out of inmates who
have volunteered for the transfers and that future movements in all likelihood
will involve prisoners who don't want to go. As a result, Adam predicted that
inmates rights attorneys and other groups will sue the state and push the matter
from the state courts into the federal system. "It's reckless for the state to
carry on with the transfers (given) the ruling," Adam said. "To continue to send
inmates out of state will trigger a ton of litigation, and the administration is
going to have more than a couple of disgruntled labor unions to deal with."
February 8, 2007 LA Times
Attorneys for two California prisoners on Wednesday asked a federal court to
block Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger from forcibly transferring convicts to private
lockups in other states. The challenge comes less than a week after the governor
ordered the mandatory moves to relieve overcrowding, which he said had reached
crisis levels in most of the state's 33 prisons. Close to 400 California inmates
already have transferred voluntarily to private prisons in Tennessee and Arizona
under a program that began in November. Schwarzenegger authorized the mandatory
moves because so few convicts had agreed to go. In papers filed with the U.S.
9th Circuit Court of Appeals, Los Angeles civil rights lawyer Stephen Yagman
asked for an order barring the forced transfers of inmates David Diaz and Paul
Blumberg — and others in similar circumstances. On Wednesday, a three-judge
panel issued an order instructing the Schwarzenegger administration to file a
response before a hearing Feb. 20. The order also said the court had been
assured Diaz and Blumberg would not be forcibly transferred before then. Diaz is
incarcerated at Corcoran State Prison, in the San Joaquin Valley, for attempted
murder and related charges. Blumberg was sentenced to life for attempted murder
and is housed at Chuckawalla Valley State Prison in Blythe. Both men have filed
habeas corpus appeals in federal court, and Yagman argues that because those are
pending, the inmates may not be transferred out of state. The mandatory
transfers also would violate their constitutional right to due process, he said.
December 31, 2006 AP
California no longer plans to transfer more than 1,200 of its inmates to an
Indiana state prison, an official said. Trina Randall, New Castle Correctional
Facility's public information officer, on Thursday confirmed to The
Courier-Times that the deal had fallen through. The plan was thwarted because of
a lawsuit against California over the possible transfer, and a lack of inmates
willing to volunteer to make the cross-country move. Gov. Mitch Daniels
announced in October a contract between California and Florida-based GEO Group
Inc., the company Indiana hired to operate the New Castle prison. He said 1,260
inmates would be transferred to Indiana in a deal that was to have created 200
Indiana jobs. The deal was part of plans to alleviate prison overcrowding in
California, and the Indiana prison was to be paid $63 per day to house each of
that state's inmates, with $15 of that going to state government. Daniels had
said the state would make about $6.2 million in each of the next two years. The
medium-security prison in New Castle, 40 miles east of Indianapolis, has a
capacity of 2,416 but has only 1,068 inmates. But a news release earlier this
week from the Indiana Department of Correction termed the transfer as "not
likely." It said that the DOC was working with another state on an agreement
similar to the California deal. "We are in the process of reviewing a proposal
from that jurisdiction," said DOC Commissioner David Donahue.
December 2, 2006 The Sacramento Bee
California's prison health czar awarded a pharmacy management services
contract two months ago "in blatant violation of California law, state
competitive bidding requirements and fundamental principles of fair dealing," a
losing bidder charged in papers filed this week in San Francisco federal court.
In asking U.S. District Court Judge Thelton Henderson to set aside the contract,
attorneys for Public Health Service Bureau, LLC, said in their motion filed
Monday that prison health care receiver Robert Sillen awarded the contract to
Maxor National Pharmacy Services Corp. "in such a way as to create the
appearance of collusion and 'cronyism' between himself and Maxor." The motion
represents the first legal challenge to the sweeping authority Henderson granted
Sillen when he created the receivership earlier this year to oversee and
overhaul the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation's troubled $1.5
billion prison health care system. Sillen's appointment earlier this year
followed Henderson's May 2005 ruling that medical delivery services in the
prison system violated constitutional standards. The judge found that the
system's shoddy health care was responsible for as many as 34 unnecessary inmate
deaths and that the prison system was incapable of stopping the carnage on its
own. But in going after prison pharmacy services, Sillen let Maxor tailor the
management bid to its own liking, kept the Request for Proposal secret, "refused
to answer questions from qualified bidders and ultimately awarded the contract
to the one bidder that had the inside track all along," the Oakland-based Public
Health group's motion read. "To ratify a public contract awarded in such a
manner flies in the face ... of public contract law declared by the Legislature
to protect the taxpayers from fraud, corruption and carelessness," it added.
Attorneys for Public Health said the contract was worth between $80 million and
$100 million. John Ward, the chief executive officer of the Amarillo,
Texas-based Maxor, said the contract was worth less than that, but he refused to
identify its value. Ward referred questions on the size of the contract to
Sillen's California Prison Health Care Receivership Corp., whose spokeswoman,
Rachael Kagan, said she didn't know what it was worth and that the people who
did weren't in the office Friday. Kagan declined to comment on the motion,
saying her office was in the process of reviewing it. Kagan said she didn't know
if the contract had been "fully awarded" or officially signed yet. A Jan. 22
hearing has been tentatively scheduled in San Francisco to hear the motion. In
creating the receiver's office, Henderson, in his Feb. 14 order, said the
appointee "shall make all reasonable efforts" to do the job "in a manner
consistent with California state laws, regulations and contracts." The judge
also empowered the receiver to seek and obtain court authority to suspend state
contracting requirements if they impede his efforts to fix the health care
system. On Nov. 16, Sillen jolted the Capitol with his testimony at the Little
Hoover Commission where he said he was prepared to have federal marshals put the
bite on the state treasury to pay for California's prison health care if that's
what it took to get the system on track. He also threatened to waive state laws
and civil service protections and seek contempt-of-court citations against
prison system officials who tried to impede him. "We're on our way," Sillen told
the commission. Long plagued by high vacancy rates and inefficiencies that have
cost taxpayers tens of millions of dollars in unnecessary costs per year, the
prison system's pharmacy services were one of Sillen's first targets once he
took his post. The receiver's office put out the bid for the pharmacy management
contract on Aug. 18 to correct what Sillen's office characterized as
"particularly grave problems" in the prisons' drug delivery system. The Request
for Proposal said the scope of the contract called for a contractor that could
implement a "road map" previously outlined in an audit the receiver commissioned
Maxor to conduct. On Oct. 20, the contract was awarded -- "not surprisingly,"
according to the motion -- to Maxor. Key to the "road map," the Public Health
Service Bureau's court papers said, was Maxor's recommendation that the prison
system administer drugs to inmates out of a "central fill" distribution system,
which the Texas company already had up and running in its own state. Ward, the
Maxor CEO, denied that his company tailored the audit's "road map" to its own
specifications. "We had no way of knowing it would go any further than our
recommendation," Ward said. The CEO said his firm has "absolutely not" had any
pre-existing relationship with Sillen. Public Health Service Bureau's court
papers said the award amounted to "misconduct" on the receiver's part because
the bid wasn't published in any newspapers or in the State Contracts Register as
required by state law. The motion said the Oakland group didn't find out about
the contract until eight days after the bid went out. When the Public Health
outfit sent questions to the receiver's office for details on the contract,
Sillen never responded, the motion said. "That tells me he didn't want to see
any responsive bids because he wanted to issue it to Maxor -- isn't it obvious?"
Alton Burkhalter, the attorney for the Public Health Service Bureau, said in an
interview. The Public Health Service Bureau is a "pharmacy benefits
administrator and information management company," according to its Web site.
The firm already administers the state's $250 million AIDS Drug Assistance
Program. "We don't think this was a fair contract," said Public Health's
president and CEO, Eric Flowers. "We don't think it's fair for the people of
California, and we don't think it's an effective solution for the prisoners."
Maxor identifies itself in press releases as "a leading expert in correctional
health care," with a current and past client list that includes the Texas prison
system, for which it re-engineered pharmacy services when the agency was under
federal court supervision. Other listed clients include the Denver County Jail
and the Colorado Department of Corrections.
November 22, 2006 AP
A state judge decided Wednesday to let California send 2,260 inmates to
Indiana and four other states to relieve prison crowding, though she said the
transfers may be illegal. Two state employee unions "are reasonably likely" to
win their lawsuit against the state next year, but can't prove they are
suffering enough immediate irreparable harm to justify a preliminary injunction
in the meantime, ruled Sacramento Superior Court Judge Gail Ohanesian. Any
damages the unions suffer are more than offset by the "extreme peril" created by
keeping more than 173,000 inmates in space designed for fewer than 100,000,
Ohanesian said.
November 2, 2006 KESP
A Sacramento County judge today rejected state employee unions' attempt to
temporarily block California's plans to move more than two thousand inmates to
other states. But Judge Patrick Marlette set another hearing for later this
month. The judge says that will give the unions another chance to argue that
Governor Schwarzenegger is violating the state Constitution by shipping the
inmates to private prisons in Arizona, Indiana, Oklahoma and Tennessee this
month to relieve crowding in the nation's largest state prison system. The
unions say Schwarzenegger is illegally sidestepping the state's civil service
system and the usual contracting procedures. Schwarzenegger's attorney says the
move is needed to relieve dangerous conditions and the possibility that a judge
could order the early release of inmates.
October 31, 2006 Sacramento Bee
Two major public employee unions Monday filed a lawsuit to block the
California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation from transferring more
than 2,000 inmates to private prisons in other states. Representatives of the
California Correctional Peace Officers Association and the Service Employees
International Union Local 1000 filed the suit in Sacramento Superior Court. It
seeks to stop the transfers on grounds that Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger
overstepped his legal authority in seeking the moves based on prison
overcrowding. Although California has used private prisons for years within its
own boundaries, CCPOA Vice President Chuck Alexander said the in-state
facilities received approval from the Legislature while the out-of-state plan
has not. "I think that's the fundamental difference," Alexander said at a press
conference at CCPOA headquarters in West Sacramento. Representatives of the
CCPOA and SEIU were joined at the press conference by state Sen. Gloria Romero,
D-East Los Angeles, and officials from other labor and community groups. Romero
said that private incarceration is "an abdication of the will of the people" and
"an abdication of responsibility" on the part of the state.
October 28, 2006
The Star Press
Talking about how inmates re-enter society after serving time in prison is a
touchy subject here, as residents worry about the 1,260 California inmates who
are headed to the New Castle Correctional Facility. So, when Indiana Department
of Correction Commissioner J. David Donahue came to New Castle on Friday for a
town hall meeting to talk about the road to re-entry, he knew he'd have to
address public concerns about the issue. Donahue, appointed by Gov. Mitch
Daniels in 2005 as the leader of the DOC, said questions about where and how
those California inmates will be released are among the most-frequently asked.
And though the deal should bring with it no expense to local taxpayers, Donahue
did acknowledge there are some instances when the county has "certain inherent
responsibilities" because the prison is located there. That likely means that in
the event an inmate is charged with a crime while behind bars, Henry County
Prosecutor Kit Crane's expenses would remain the county's responsibility. That's
not the answer Henry County officials wanted, as Henry County Councilman Richard
Bouslog hoped the county could recoup its court expenses. Bouslog was among the
many elected officials in the crowd of the old circuit courtroom inside the
courthouse Friday afternoon. Members of the county council and board of
commissioners, as well as candidates for political office, made up the majority
of the 50-person crowd.
October 21, 2006 Sacramento Bee
The first transfers of California inmates to private, out-of-state prisons
are scheduled to take place next month under two no-bid contracts the
overstuffed Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation signed Friday. Under
the deals worked out with the GEO Group and the Corrections Corporation of
America, the state will move 2,260 inmates out of its jampacked prisons over the
next 120 days to private institutions in Indiana, Arizona, Oklahoma and
Tennessee. Corrections officials say the separate deals will help stem its
emergency overcrowding crisis, but union officials opposed to the transfers
contend they will undermine public accountability and shift responsibility for
the tough business of prison administration to profit-driven corporate
boardrooms. Newspaper reports compiled on a Web site run by the Private
Corrections Institute in Florida paint a different picture of the CCA prisons,
however. The stories cited riots and inmate drug dealing at Diamondback, more
violence and drug issues at Florence, inmate complaints over phone rates at
North Fork and the unexplained death of a prisoner at West Tennessee.
October 6, 2006 Courier Journal
Up to 1,200 medium-security prisoners from California will be housed in the
state's underused New Castle Correctional Facility, Gov. Mitch Daniels announced
yesterday. Daniels said the deal he struck with California Gov. Arnold
Schwarzenegger will result in a $6.2 million profit for Indiana. Indiana
officials initiated the negotiations, which took four or five months, after
reading about California's prison-crowding crisis, Daniels said. GEO Group, the
private company that runs the prison in east-central Indiana, will hire 200
additional workers to oversee the new prisoners. "We saw an opportunity and
contacted California officials several months ago," Daniels said. "We look at
every way we can to be creative and businesslike, and this is a win for
everyone."
October 6, 2006
Ludington Daily News
A California prison overcrowding emergency declaration could speed up that
state’s contract negotiations with GEO Group, which owns the Lake County prison.
California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation spokesman Bill Sessa
said the agency is continuing to talk with three private prison companies, one
of which is GEO, to negotiate contracts to move prisoners to out-of-state
facilities. “We’re going to continue contract negotiations with three companies
and whoever else jumps in,” Sessa said. Officials from GEO said they are
continuing talks with California. “We’re looking forward to working with the
state,” said Pablo Paez, director of corporate communications at GEO. “We’re
working with them and we look forward to work through the process.” GEO has
available beds at three facilities, including the Lake County site, Paez said,
noting that California officials have visited the facility sites. Paez said he
has no specific timeline for contract talks, but added that the
state-of-emergency declaration demonstrates “they have an immediate need to send
up to 5,000 inmates out of state.”
October 6, 2006
Inland Valley Daily Bulletin
Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger's recent declaration of an emergency in state
prisons will mean two new possibilities for inmates at the California
Institution for Men and other prisons: doing time at private prisons and doing
time in other states. Special Section: Criminal Neglect Schwarzenegger's
proclamation makes it possible for California to contract for prison beds with
private operators in other states - a proposal the governor had sought earlier
this year but was rebuffed by the Legislature. "Our prisons are now beyond
maximum capacity, and we must act immediately and aggressively to resolve this
issue," he said Wednesday. But experts questioned the wisdom of the move, noting
that placing prisoners in out-of-state facilities has in the past led to
violence. "There's been lots of problems with inmates being shipped out, in
particular if they're put into a facility with multijurisdictional inmates,"
said Ken Kopczynski, of the Florida-based Private Corrections Institute.
"California inmates are under California law. If they have Oklahoma inmates, or
Texas inmates, they all have to be handled separately." Disparity in treatment
of prisoners from several states was one cause identified in a 2004 riot where
inmates alternately smashed, flooded and torched a private institution in
Colorado, Kopczynski noted. In that incident, prisoners from different states
-Colorado, Washington and Wyoming - felt they were being treated unfairly, since
each state paid different wages for inmate labor. Other problems can arise when
inmates from different states get together to form their own gangs, or when the
distance from their families and support networks is too great, making
rehabilitation less likely. Kopczynski also said the private corrections
industry has racked up a less-than-stellar record in the past, mostly due to
cost-saving efforts such as using low-wage guards and cutting corners on
security.
October 5, 2006
The Press-Enterprise
The governor's emergency order to transfer California inmates to other
states to ease crowding sent private-prison stocks soaring Thursday while
provoking the ire of Democratic legislators, corrections officers and inmate
advocacy groups. The state is poised this month to sign deals with private
prison operators to house California inmates in states such as Indiana. The plan
would send 2,200 inmates to other states almost immediately. Campaign Money: It
has already stirred the frustration of state legislators, who shot down a
similar proposal during a special session on prison crowding in August. Amid
accusations of cronyism and conflicts of interest, Gov. Schwarzenegger's
campaign announced Thursday that he has returned $32,000 in campaign donations
to a private prison slated to benefit from his proposal. "The Governor has a
strict policy against accepting contributions from persons or entities doing
business with the state or seeking to do business with the state and in which he
or his office might be negotiating the terms of such state contracts," wrote his
attorney in a letter to The Geo Group. The Geo Group is a Florida-based private
prison firm, and one of three firms currently negotiating with the state for
three- to five-year, no-bid contracts to house inmates out of state. Democrat's
Response: It reeks of "pay to play," said Senate Majority Leader Gloria Romero,
D-Los Angeles. "What it demonstrates is that the governor can't resolve this
crisis. He doesn't have the political will, and he doesn't have the stomach for
it." Romero questioned the constitutionality of forced transfers and suggested
the state concentrate on programs to reduce California's 70 percent recidivism
rate.
September 10, 2006 Sacramento Bee
The Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation is conducting an inmate
survey to see how many prisoners might be interested in serving their time out
of state -- and a Florida company that has contributed $90,000 over the years to
Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger says it would be happy to accommodate them.
Department spokesman Oscar Hidalgo said the agency can administratively transfer
inmates out of state if they volunteer for the move and if the contracts with
out-of-state operators do not exceed a year. Longer term deals, Hidalgo said,
would require legislative approval. "If there's a willing inmate and a vendor,
we can do this on our own right now," Hidalgo said. One major private prison
company, the GEO Group of Boca Raton, Fla., formerly known as Wackenhut
Corrections Corp., has expressed interest in housing California inmates at its
facilities in Michigan, Indiana and Louisiana. GEO currently operates four
private prisons in California. It also contributed $22,300 to Schwarzenegger on
Aug. 25, in the last week of the legislative session, when lawmakers declined to
act on proposals designed to ease prison overcrowding in California. One bill
would have required inmate approval for out-of-state transfers. In legislative
hearings, GEO expressed support for an involuntary transfer plan. Altogether,
GEO has contributed $90,300 to Schwarzenegger going back to 2003.
September 7,
2006 Ludington Daily News
A deal that might have supplied California inmates to the former Michigan
Youth Correctional Facility in Lake County could be in jeopardy. Gov. Arnold
Schwarzenegger and the California’s Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation
(CDCR) proposed sending inmates to out-of-state facilities — potentially
including the Lake County prison — without getting the inmates’ permission.
However, the future of the proposal is unclear. The California Assembly refused
to vote on the measure despite the California Senate passing a bill allowing the
transfers only with the inmate’s permission, which is current California law.
The California legislature, a part-time legislature, left session for the year
Friday without approving Schwarzenegger’s four-bill package. The bills faced
opposition by Republicans in the Assembly as well as the corrections officer
union and garnered only lukewarm support from Democrats. In addition, Republican
Gov. Schwarzenegger also faces a challenge from Democrat Phil Angelides in the
November election. The Baldwin area facility was mentioned as a possible
recipient of California inmates, and officials from California reportedly
visited the site earlier this summer. Pablo Paez, communications director for
GEO Group which owns the Lake County prison, said he had “nothing new to report”
with regard to any deal to house inmates there. Paez said GEO has been in
contact with California and with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement
regarding possibly renting bed space at the facility a few miles north of
Baldwin. Refusing to name where else GEO is seeking rentals, Paez said “the
company remains active in marketing our facility.”
September 13, 2005 Bakersfield Californian
A company that wanted to reopen a private prison in Bakersfield under a no-bid
contract had a clear conflict of interest because it had hired two recent
retirees from the Department of Corrections, the state auditor said Tuesday. But
the auditor concluded there was no conflict of interest by another company that
was awarded a no-bid contract to operate a prison in McFarland, even though it
had put Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger's former finance director on the board of a
subsidiary. Those were the key points in a report by Auditor Elaine Howle's
office that was ordered by lawmakers upset about the handling of the
department's decision to reopen the two facilities that had been shut down
barely a year before. State Sen. Gloria Romero, D-Los Angeles, requested the
audit in January because she said the contract for the McFarland facility
"smells bad." That contract was awarded to GEO Group Inc., the same
firm that had operated it for years before it was shut down. The contract drew
fire because the real estate trust that owns the facility and leases it to GEO
put former state budget chief Donna Arduin on its board of directors shortly
before it was offered the contract late last year. The audit report said that
did not involve a conflict of interest because GEO has a 10-year lease on the
property from the subsidiary that began long before Arduin joined the company
and before the state decided to reopen the facility. Besides, it noted, GEO was
the only possible operator because its subsidiary owned the facility. But the
department's handling of a contract to reopen the Mesa Verde Community
Correctional Facility on Golden State Avenue in Bakersfield came in for sharp
criticism by the auditor. The bidder, Massachusetts-based CiviGenics Inc., did
not disclose the fact it had hired two former high-level department officials,
at least one of whom contacted the department about the contract. They had both
retired from the department less than a year before. State law bars top
officials from being involved with state contracts for at least a year after
they leave state service.
September 13,
2005 AP
California's
prison population is at a record high, officials said Tuesday, as the state
auditor panned the corrections system's last attempt to deal with sudden
crowding. The news comes as the state auditor reported that two former
high-ranking state corrections employees may have violated conflict of interest
laws when they contacted their former colleagues as the state was opening two
private prisons. One contract was later rescinded in part because of the
conflict allegations. The department wasted an undetermined amount of money on
the aborted project before it had permission from the Department of General
Services, auditors found. Two high-level department retirees had gone to work
for private prison operator CiviGenics Inc. and worked with their former
colleagues on the contract within a year after leaving state government, in
possible violation of conflict of interest laws, auditors found. They faulted
the Marlborough, Mass.-based contractor for not disclosing the employees'
background, and the department for not requiring disclosure. Auditors decided
there was no conflict of interest by a former state Department of Finance
director who went to work for the second prison contractor, GEO Group Inc.
January 2, 2004
Two of Kern County's private prisons are officially shut down, after the state
pulled funding and moved all the inmates. Mesa Verde Community
Correctional Facility on Golden State Avenue in Bakersfield, and the McFarland
Community Correctional Facility in McFarland were finishing closing down
Wednesday after losing state funding. One other private prison in Riverside
County was also closed. Former Gov. Gray Davis wanted to shut down the
prisons last year, but the Legislature was against the closures. Davis officials
had said that the closures would save $400,000 the first year and $900,000 every
year after. But McFarland's city administrator said the closure of the
prison will mean lost jobs and a drop in revenue for the city. The prison
industry is one of the city's largest employers, said Anthony B. Lopez, interim
McFarland city administrator. "That (losing jobs) in itself is a
detriment," Lopez said. The water and sewer service that was provided
by the city for prison use is also a major revenue source, Lopez said. The city
stands to lose $260,000 a year, he said. The city plans to negotiate
reopening the facility and maybe housing federal inmates at the facility
"hopefully in the very near future," Lopez said. More than 100
full and part-time employees will lose their jobs at Mesa Verde which run by
Alternative Programs Inc.,, said Gary White, the company's president.
White said the closures were more to appease the state prison guards' union than
to save money for the state. State officials have consistently denied
that, saying it was a purely budgetary decision to close the prisons.
Officials with the union, officially called the California Correctional Peace
Officers Association, could not be reached for comment Wednesday. But the
CCPOA has made no secret of its opposition to private prisons. Union officials
insist it is due to a belief that prisons should be publicly owned, not run for
profit at taxpayers' expense, not anger that they are non-union. The
closed McFarland prison was operated by the former Wackenhut Corrections Corp.,
and now the GEO Group Inc. The company runs two other prisons in McFarland that
will remain open. The closed prisons housed more than 500 inmates
combined. Displaced inmates have been moved to various locations across the
state, said California Department of Corrections spokesman Russ Heimrich said.
(Bakersfield Californian)
California
Legislature
June 5, 2008 San Francisco Chronicle
Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger was within his rights to declare a state of emergency
at California's overcrowded prisons in 2006 and begin transferring inmates out
of state, an appeals court ruled Wednesday over the objections of the prison
guards union. The ruling by the state Third District Court of Appeal in
Sacramento overturned a judge's decision and was welcomed by Schwarzenegger, who
is separately defending the state against lawsuits by inmates seeking to reduce
the overall prison population and improve the prisons' health care system. A
federal judge has transferred control of prison health care in California to a
court-appointed manager after ruling that the system violated constitutional
standards. There are nearly 160,000 inmates in the 33 state prisons, which were
designed to hold about 83,000. The state is planning construction that will
expand the capacity of state prisons and county jails by 53,000. A referee
appointed by a federal court panel has proposed measures to reduce the prison
population by 27,000 over four years, to 133,000. The measures would include
alternatives to prison for some parole violators and felons facing short
sentences. Wednesday's ruling "comes at a critical juncture in our prison reform
efforts," Schwarzenegger said in a statement. "I am pleased that their decision
allows out-of-state transfers to continue while our comprehensive reforms to
reduce overcrowding are fully implemented." Laurie Hepler, a lawyer for the
prison guards' union and another prison employee union that challenged the
inmate transfers, said her clients disagreed with the ruling and would appeal to
the state Supreme Court. Schwarzenegger issued the order in October 2006 after a
special legislative session on prison overcrowding fizzled, with Democrats
seeking changes in sentencing laws and Republicans calling for prison expansion.
As the inmate population continued to climb, 16,000 prisoners occupied bunks in
prison gyms and other temporary quarters. Schwarzenegger has said as many as
8,000 inmates could be shipped out of state. So far, nearly 3,900 prisoners have
been transferred to out-of-state prisons run by private companies under
contracts with California. The transfers have continued despite a ruling in
April 2007 by a Sacramento County judge that Schwarzenegger had acted illegally.
Superior Court Judge Gail Ohanesian agreed with the unions that state law allows
a governor to issue an emergency order only when local officials need state help
in responding to a disaster, and that the use of private prison employees
violated civil service laws. The appeals court had put Ohanesian's ruling on
hold while the state appealed. In its ruling Wednesday, the court said the
governor can issue orders to respond to emergencies in state institutions that
may endanger residents. In this case, the court said, the lack of space in state
prisons was causing overcrowding in local jails, forcing counties to release
some inmates who might commit more crimes. Overcrowding also increased the risk
of diseases that could spread outside the prisons and had led to local water
pollution from sewage spills caused by overtaxed prison wastewater systems, the
court said. The court also said California's civil service rules allow the state
to employ private contractors when public employees are not available to meet
urgent needs. The planned expansion of state prisons will take years to
complete, and the prison system will need five years to eliminate staffing
shortages, the court said. "California cannot build or retrofit the prisons
needed overnight, no matter how much money it invests to solve the problem,"
Presiding Justice Arthur Scotland said in the 3-0 ruling. The only available
lockups are in other states and are staffed by private employees, he said.
March 21, 2008 The California Majority Report
Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger -- who railed against special interests
during his recall campaign and has since shattered all fundraising efforts --
has quietly been padding his campaign accounts with hundreds of thousands of
dollars during the past few weeks. In the last week, Schwarzenegger has added
five- and six-figure donations from health care interests, pharmaceutical
companies, homebuilders, and private prison companies -- just as he begins
reviewing legislation being passed in the legislature reviewing those
industries. For example, he has received $25,000 from Pacific West Pharmacy,
$5,000 from the Corrections Corporation of America, and $25,000 from General
Motors Corporation. The funds have been funneled to this "California Dream Team"
account, one of several the governor has to raise campaign cash. It should be
noted, however, that Schwarzenegger cannot run for re-election. Fascinating that
Schwarzenegger can shake down the wealthy and contributions from millions in
campaign money but rules out Democratic proposals to tax these very same
interests to pay their fair share for our kids education.
March 9, 2008 Sacramento Bee
As far as the inmates are concerned, it's fine if California pays tens of
millions of dollars more to their private-prison captors. They like the relaxed
atmosphere in the private sector, not to mention the satellite TV that on a
recent Friday flashed plenty of poolside bikini action from a Spanish-language
soap opera. "You're relaxed here," said Don Chandler, 43, of West Sacramento,
who was propped up on his bunk at Golden State Modified Community Correctional
Facility while finishing up a stint for violating parole on an underlying
domestic-violence conviction. "You're comfortable. You can enjoy yourself here."
Although California has been contracting with private correctional facilities
for 22 years to cope with overcrowding, saving money in the process, costs are
about to go up. This year, Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger's state corrections agency
is proposing a five-year, $67 million increase to one company, GEO Group Inc.
The proposal would bump up the daily rate the state pays per inmate by 50
percent, which the company says it needs to increase the minimum pay of its
officers from $10 an hour to $14.70. It is a deal that will require approval
from the Legislature and one that figures to attract an added level of scrutiny.
State Sen. Mike Machado, chairman of the budget subcommittee that oversees
prison spending, promised a "tough look" when he examines the proposed deal for
the GEO Group, especially in light of the remaining $8 billion budget deficit
projected through June 2009. "Any proposal to spend money with this type of
deficit raises serious questions," the Linden Democrat said. Corrections
officials say private prisons are crucial to finding more space to house
inmates, while critics in the public employee unions castigate them for lower
pay scales that they say attract a less-than-professional work force. Private
prisons generally house lower-risk, healthier inmates in the final 18 months of
their terms. It's a class of prisoner that costs less to incarcerate than the
dangerous, the sick and the long-term who require added expenses for things such
as security and medical care. On a recent visit to the Golden State facility, 25
miles north of Bakersfield, inmates lauded the prison for its easier feel, which
they said contrasts sharply with the oppressive environment of state
institutions marked by overcrowding, violence and control. "Right here is love,
compared to where I've been," said inmate William Cook, 27, of Newark, who
previously walked the yards at San Quentin, Pleasant Valley and Lancaster. "Here
you get all the football games, you get movies every day. It's real easy to do
your time here. You don't have to worry about nothing – no politics right here."
GEO spokesman Pablo Paez said the satellite TV cost is "minimal" and
characterized it as a "privilege" that makes inmates want to behave. "It
enhances the security and the safety of the facility," Paez said. Two veteran
GEO officers, Tim Harrison and Melissa Barrientos, said in interviews that they
like their jobs and the company that employs them, even though they have topped
out on the firm's pay scales at $15.70 an hour. The hourly base for a top-scale
state correctional officer is $35. "We know we work in a private institution,"
said Harrison, an 11-year employee. "The state has received training in firearms
and batons, and we're not allowed to possess those things because we don't have
the training." Harrison and Barrientos said they work about 20 hours of overtime
a week. They said they get good health benefits and a 401(k), but no pensions.
"Some people are embarrassed to admit they work here, because of all the stuff
that was said about this place" by former employees, Barrientos said. "It's not
that bad. It's a good place." Even though she likes working for GEO, Barrientos
disclosed she is taking a test to become a state correctional officer. GEO
officials support that, and Golden State Warden Chris Strickland sees his prison
as "a great steppingstone." UC Berkeley Labor Center Chairman Ken Jacobs said
there should be no surprise in the company's relatively modest salary scales.
"That's how they make their profits," said Jacobs, whose research focuses on
public employment and living wages, among other topics. "Labor is one of the
places where people tend to squeeze." On the non-custody side, teachers in the
GEO prisons start out at $18.15 an hour, according to the company. The rate is
substantially below most starting categories in the state prisons. Eric Beltran,
31, who teaches a computer class, has been in his current job for about two
years, working his way up from the kitchen. His qualifications for the computer
job, he said, include working with computers when he was in the motor pool in
the Marines and a "couple courses" he took in his one year at Bakersfield
College. "I want to keep climbing the ladder," Beltran said. Fewer than 100
Golden State inmates currently are enrolled in educational or vocational
classes. GEO officials said they hope to increase that number to 250 inmates
with the new contract. Mike Poulson, 48, a drug offender from San Diego, slapped
dominoes with fellow inmates – including some of other races, a rare sight in
state prisons – and said he likes the GEO prison, compared with sardine cans
he's been in such as Solano and Chino. He just wishes the place had more rehab
programs, or more job opportunities – such as working in the kitchen – which he
said are lacking at Golden State. "I don't like to sit around doing nothing,"
Poulson said. GEO's deal would apply to three of the five prisons it owns in the
state – Golden State, Central Valley Modified Community Correctional Facility,
also located in McFarland, and Desert View Modified Community Correctional
Facility in Adelanto, San Bernardino County. The proposed increase comes as
Schwarzenegger seeks to grant early releases over the next two years to 22,000
prisoners. Scott Kernan, the prison agency's chief of adult operations, said the
proposed contract increase will be canceled if the releases go through.
Corrections officials say the raise is long overdue, that GEO had been operating
below market value until the state increased its daily, per-inmate rate from $40
to $60 in December. "I know some people's sensibilities are bruised, but I think
it's a reasonable rate increase, and it's going to be for five years into the
future," Kernan said. GEO Western Region Vice President Ed Brown defended the
contract. According to the company, the deal reflects the increase in minimum
officer pay from $10 to $14.70 an hour; added costs for food, health care and
utilities; the tab for buying the prisons it formerly leased; and a GEO promise
to ramp up inmate rehabilitation. "This was an opportunity for a clean sheet of
paper, rebid, with practical figures based on 2007 dollars," Brown said. "It's
in my opinion reasonable in all respects." Together, the three facilities house
about 1,800 of the 5,600 inmates in the state's 13 community prisons – seven
private, six owned by cities. GEO is the second-largest private prison company
in the United States, behind Correctional Corp. of America. It contributed
$68,000 to Schwarzenegger's campaign committees in 2003 and 2005. Its chief
executive officer, George C. Zoley, made $3.7 million last year, not counting
stock options, according to Salary.com. GEO's profits jumped 25 percent last
year to $41 million on revenue of $1 billion, according to its 2007 annual
report. The company's $60-a-day rate per inmate compares with the $118 the state
pays on average to accommodate an inmate in one of its own prisons every day;
the $77 it pays counties to house state prisoners; and the $63 it pays on its
out-of-state contracts. The California Correctional Peace Officers Association
voiced strident opposition to the deal. Union spokesman Ryan Sherman called it
"corporate welfare." "If GEO is complaining they need extra money to pay their
staff more, that's a joke," Sherman said. "If GEO wants to pay them $15 (to
start), they can do that right now."
July 23, 2007 Fresno Bee
Two federal judges on Monday ordered creation of a special panel to
recommend ways to relieve California's overcrowded prisons, a move that could
lead to the capping of the inmate population or the early release of some
prisoners. In doing so, the judges rejected the main solution set forth by Gov.
Arnold Schwarzenegger and state lawmakers to address a crisis that has been
building for decades. Last spring, they agreed to an ambitious $7.8 billion
program to build 53,000 new prison and jail cells. The judges said that plan,
submitted to the courts in June, will only make matters worse for the California
Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation. The state can't hire enough guards
and medical professionals to provide proper care and oversight for the inmates
it has now, let alone the thousands more who might be added through the building
program. "From all that presently appears, new beds will not alleviate this
problem but will aggravate it," U.S. District Court Judge Lawrence Karlton of
Sacramento wrote. Schwarzenegger said he will appeal the judges' decision to
create the three-judge panel.
June 14, 2007 NBC 11
A no-show at a Thursday hearing fueled the controversy over moving prisoners
across state lines against their will, NBC11 reported. The state committee on
prison operations was ready to ask tough questions of the private company set to
transfer inmates out of California during a hearing Thursday. However, the
Corrections Corporation of America representative was a no-show. "Here we have a
$56 million contract, and it guarantees them payment whether we have one
prisoner or 1,000 prisoners -- and it's a guaranteed contract," Assemblyman Todd
Spitzer said. "And they can't send one official to California to answer
questions of the legislators?" California has already sent 400 inmates to
private prisons in Tennessee and Arizona. Those inmates were volunteers. A video
used as a recruitment tool encourages prisoners to volunteer to move to less
crowded facilities out of state. The Department of Corrections created the
video, which tells inmates they will have bigger cells, dozens of cable channels
and all night parties if they move to a prison in Tennessee. Under the prison
reform package signed last month by Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger, California will
soon begin sending up to 8,000 prisoners out of state -- whether they like it or
not -- prompting concerns about potential riots. Bill Sessa of the California
Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation said there's no safety concern
whatsoever. "We move hundreds of thousands of inmates a year against their
will," Sessa said. "Moving them to a prison in another state is really no
different." Not everyone is enthused about sending prisoners out of state to
ease prison overcrowding. Critics said there is a better way to go. Matt Gray of
Taxpayers for Improving Public Safety said that the 20,000 foreign national
inmates in prisons on "our dime, California's dime," could be transferred into
federal custody and begin the deportation process back to their country so
Californians would no longer have to pay to keep them housed. Prison authorities
said undocumented immigrants would be among the first inmates screened for
involuntary transfers. The Corrections Corporation of America told NBC11 it
didn't show up because of a scheduling conflict and because it did not receive
enough advance notice.
June 2, 2007 Sacramento Bee
State corrections officials resumed transferring inmates to out-of-state
prisons Friday, moving 38 convicts by bus to Arizona. The transfers had been
placed on hold since November, when two public employee unions convinced a
Sacramento judge that sending inmates out of state violated California's civil
service laws. Superior Court Judge Gail Ohanesian's ruling has since been stayed
pending an appeal to the 3rd District Court of Appeal by the Schwarzenegger
administration. Oral arguments have yet to be scheduled. Corrections spokesman
Seth Unger said state officials "believe we have statutory authority" to go
ahead with more transfers, and he suggested that if the administration lost its
appeal, it would not pose a major problem. "We'll cross that bridge when we come
to it," Unger said. Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger obtained legislative approval in
the recently enacted Assembly Bill 900 prison construction and rehabilitation
package to transfer up to 8,000 inmates, involuntarily if it comes to that. Only
inmates volunteering for the out-of-state placement were transferred Friday,
however. The California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation is planning
to transfer as many as 400 inmates a month to help ease overcrowding, with
18,000 inmates now living in gyms, dayrooms and other spaces not designed to
house them. "Temporary out-of-state inmate transfers will provide immediate
relief to California's prison system while the rest of the governor's
comprehensive reforms are implemented," Corrections Secretary Jim Tilton said in
a prepared statement. Tilton said the transfers "will also give us breathing
room" to try to pick up the system's rehabilitation effort and also to help
improve its medical delivery system, which a San Francisco federal judge has
declared unconstitutional. Friday's transfers to the Florence Detention Center
in Arizona increased to 218 the number of California inmates being housed in the
prison, which is owned and operated by the Correctional Corporation of America.
Another 76 state prisoners have been transferred to the West Tennessee Detention
Facility, another CCA-owned prison not far from Memphis. The California
Correctional Peace Officers Association and Service Employees International
Union Local 1000 were the unions filing the suit last fall that temporarily
blocked the transfers. CCPOA spokesman Lance Corcoran said Friday that even
though the most recent transfers involved only inmates who the department said
wanted to go out of state, the decision to move out prisoners who don't want to
go "is absolutely one of the most dangerous things this administration has
utilized." Corcoran said the prison system has been "marketing these
(out-of-state) institutions much like cruise ships," yet still has fallen short
of obtaining anywhere near the 19,000 inmates the corrections agency initially
said were interested in the transfers. "Very quickly, they're going to have to
move them involuntarily, then we'll see what happens from there," Corcoran said.
Union leaders have said they expect inmates who don't want to be transferred out
of state to wage intense struggles to keep from being removed from their cells.
May 24, 2007 California Aggie
A state appellate court gave the go-ahead for Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger
to resume transferring inmates from overcrowded state prisons into out-of-state,
privately run correctional facilities earlier this week. The decision came as
deliberation over a lawsuit filed by the prison guard's union to end the
transfer practice carries on. The May 21 announcement by the court will allow
the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation to prepare the
transfer of up to 300 inmates in June, according to CDCR spokesperson Bill Sessa.
Sessa said that by the end of the year, 5,000 prisoners are expected to be
shipped out of state, and by March 2009, the number of inmates will reach 8,000.
"We think it gives us an opportunity to put some breaking room into the prison
system," Sessa said. The governor's plan to send prisoners out of state to
alleviate overcrowding in the California state prison system was originally
proposed in late 2006 by eliciting prisoners to voluntarily move into
correctional facilities managed by the Corrections Corporation of America,
located in Tennessee and Arizona. Only 360 inmates opted to relocate to the
privately run prisons, prompting Schwarzenegger to make the transfers for
selected prisoners mandatory in February 2007. The move brought about a lawsuit
filed by the California Correctional Peace Officers Association to block the
practice, calling it an unconstitutional and desperate attempt at solving
prolonged prison overcrowding. Sacramento County Superior Court Judge Gail
Ohanesian ruled in favor of the CCPOA in a Feb. 20 decision, saying the governor
inappropriately used his powers to declare that the crowded state prison system
was in a state of emergency. The Schwarzenegger administration appealed the
judge's ruling and was granted a temporary stay - allowing the transfers to
resume. The CCPOA disapproved of this week's decision by the appellate court,
saying prison guards will be at higher risk for assaults when forcing inmates
who are unwilling to transfer into the out-of-state prisons. "All [the inmates]
have to do if they don't want to get transferred is assault the staff," said
Ryan Sherman of the CCPOA. "And now they're disqualified from going." Sherman
said the governor is resorting to transferring inmates because of the lack of a
short-term plan to solve the prison overcrowding problem. He said shipping
inmates out of state is inconsistent with recommendations from Schwarzenegger's
own staff to establish community-based correctional facilities. "His own experts
said that the best chance rehabilitation occurs when the inmates are in their
communities," Sherman said.
April 6, 2007 Sacramento Bee
The Schwarzenegger administration sought Thursday to block a court ruling
that the governor's program transferring inmates out of state is "unlawful." In
the meantime, the administration is taking the ruling by Sacramento Superior
Court Judge Gail Ohanesian to the state's 3rd District Court of Appeal.
Ohanesian ruled against the administration on Feb. 20, but the official order
blocking the order wasn't entered until Monday. The state filed its appeal on
Tuesday, and on Thursday filed the stay order on Ohanesian's ruling until the
appeal is heard. In a statement, Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger said his office is
prepared to "fight to preserve our emergency efforts to address the prison
overcrowding crisis." He said the out-of-state transfers, in which hundreds of
prisoners already have been moved to private prisons in Arizona and Tennessee,
are "imperative to relieve the pressure on our overburdened prison system and
improve safety for correctional officers, staff and inmates." Ohanesian's ruling
agreed with the California Correctional Peace Officers Association and Service
Employees International Union Local 1000 that the transfers violated the state's
civil service protection laws. Her ruling also said the governor overstepped his
authority by issuing an emergency proclamation on the prison overcrowding
because the issue remains within the state's ability to control. Moreover, the
judge's ruling said, no local authorities asked the state for assistance. The
challenge to the governor's authority to declare an emergency created "wider
implications" that his appeal will seek to address, Schwarzenegger said in his
statement. "It jeopardizes my executive authority to maintain the public's
safety, the lives and property of our citizens," Schwarzenegger said. " CCPOA
attorney Gregg Adam said the administration is setting itself up for potentially
larger problems if it goes ahead with the transfers. He said the California
Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation is just about out of inmates who
have volunteered for the transfers and that future movements in all likelihood
will involve prisoners who don't want to go. As a result, Adam predicted that
inmates rights attorneys and other groups will sue the state and push the matter
from the state courts into the federal system. "It's reckless for the state to
carry on with the transfers (given) the ruling," Adam said. "To continue to send
inmates out of state will trigger a ton of litigation, and the administration is
going to have more than a couple of disgruntled labor unions to deal with."
February 21, 2007 AP
Private prison operator Corrections Corp. of America shares dropped
Wednesday morning after a judge ruled California could not transfer thousands of
prisoners out of state. In October, Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger declared a state
of emergency because of prison overcrowding and ordered that as many as 5,000
prisoners be sent to private prisons around the country. But the prison guard
union sued, and Tuesday Superior Court Judge Gail Ohanesian said the situation
was not an emergency, and the order violated the state Constitution, which bans
jobs normally done by state workers from being done by a private company. She
gave the state until June to reduce overcrowding in its prisons - rather than
work with CCA. Banc of America Securities analyst T.C. Robillard said the ruling
was not unexpected and would be appealed, though it does create a brief
psychological barrier for CCA and, thus, an opportunity for investors. "We
continue to be buyers of the stock and would use any near-term weakness as a
buying opportunity," he said. Corrections Corp. shares gave up $1.02, or 1.9
percent, to $52.35 on the New York Stock Exchange.
February 20,
2007 Sacramento Bee
A Sacramento judge Tuesday blocked California corrections officials from
transferring inmates to out of state, ruling that Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger's
declaration of a prison overcrowding emergency was "unlawful" and that the
movement of the prisoners violates the state's civil service principles.
Schwarzenegger vowed to appeal the decision issued by Superior Court Judge Gail
D. Ohanesian and the state attorney general's office has said it will seek a
stay of the ruling. More than 400 inmates already have been transferred to
private, out-of-state prisons on contracts that Ohanesian has enjoined. In her
five-page ruling, Ohanesian said Schwarzenegger's declaration violated the
state's Emergency Services Act because the prison overcrowding is a statewide
issue rather than a local disaster that would require a response from state
government. "The emergency here is not within the control of any single county
or city in California," Ohanesian wrote. "This is so not because of the
magnitude of the crisis. It is because control of the state prisons is
exclusively within the purview of state government and not local government. The
intent of the Emergency Services Act is not to give the governor extraordinary
powers to act without legislative approval in matters such as this that are
ordinarily and entirely within the control of state government." Ohanesian said
Schwarzenegger made a "good faith attempt" to resolve the crisis in which
172,000 inmates are living in space designed for about half that many but that
he acted "in excess of his authority" in proclaiming the emergency. She said the
state's arguments that the transfers did not violate constitutional civil
service protections were "unavailing" because the lack of employee services were
never cited as a reason for the transfers. The suit was brought by the
California Correctional Peace Officers Association and the Service Employees
International Union Local 1000.
February 16,
2007 Contra Costa Times
Overcrowding is fueling violence inside California's prisons and creating an
atmosphere primed for a major riot, a state attorney said Friday during court
arguments over Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger's decision to send prisoners to other
states. As an example, Deputy Attorney General Vickie Whitney cited a Dec. 30
brawl by hundreds of inmates at the California Institution for Men in Chino that
injured more than 50 inmates. "It's because of very crowded situations, and it's
a miracle that something more dangerous hasn't occurred that's going to imperil
not only correctional officers but inmates and the public," Whitney told
reporters after the court hearing. Severe overcrowding prompted Schwarzenegger
to declare an emergency in October and order thousands of inmates to be
transferred to private prisons in other states. Two state employee unions,
including the one representing prison guards, challenged the order on two
points. They said it violates the Emergency Powers Act and a provision in the
state Constitution that prohibits using private companies for jobs usually
performed by state workers. Union attorney Gregg Adams said state law reserves
emergency declarations for unforeseen disasters that overwhelm local
authorities. It should not be used to address predictable situations such as
crowding in prisons, he said. "It makes no sense to me that an illegality can be
justified by a danger to the public," he said. Sacramento County Superior Court
Judge Gail Ohanesian said Schwarzenegger's declaration might have overstepped
state law but delayed a decision in the case. The judge said she will consider
whether the public safety threat outweighs any harm to the unions.
February 8, 2007 LA Times
Attorneys for two California prisoners on Wednesday asked a federal court to
block Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger from forcibly transferring convicts to private
lockups in other states. The challenge comes less than a week after the governor
ordered the mandatory moves to relieve overcrowding, which he said had reached
crisis levels in most of the state's 33 prisons. Close to 400 California inmates
already have transferred voluntarily to private prisons in Tennessee and Arizona
under a program that began in November. Schwarzenegger authorized the mandatory
moves because so few convicts had agreed to go. In papers filed with the U.S.
9th Circuit Court of Appeals, Los Angeles civil rights lawyer Stephen Yagman
asked for an order barring the forced transfers of inmates David Diaz and Paul
Blumberg — and others in similar circumstances. On Wednesday, a three-judge
panel issued an order instructing the Schwarzenegger administration to file a
response before a hearing Feb. 20. The order also said the court had been
assured Diaz and Blumberg would not be forcibly transferred before then. Diaz is
incarcerated at Corcoran State Prison, in the San Joaquin Valley, for attempted
murder and related charges. Blumberg was sentenced to life for attempted murder
and is housed at Chuckawalla Valley State Prison in Blythe. Both men have filed
habeas corpus appeals in federal court, and Yagman argues that because those are
pending, the inmates may not be transferred out of state. The mandatory
transfers also would violate their constitutional right to due process, he said.
December 31, 2006 AP
California no longer plans to transfer more than 1,200 of its inmates to an
Indiana state prison, an official said. Trina Randall, New Castle Correctional
Facility's public information officer, on Thursday confirmed to The
Courier-Times that the deal had fallen through. The plan was thwarted because of
a lawsuit against California over the possible transfer, and a lack of inmates
willing to volunteer to make the cross-country move. Gov. Mitch Daniels
announced in October a contract between California and Florida-based GEO Group
Inc., the company Indiana hired to operate the New Castle prison. He said 1,260
inmates would be transferred to Indiana in a deal that was to have created 200
Indiana jobs. The deal was part of plans to alleviate prison overcrowding in
California, and the Indiana prison was to be paid $63 per day to house each of
that state's inmates, with $15 of that going to state government. Daniels had
said the state would make about $6.2 million in each of the next two years. The
medium-security prison in New Castle, 40 miles east of Indianapolis, has a
capacity of 2,416 but has only 1,068 inmates. But a news release earlier this
week from the Indiana Department of Correction termed the transfer as "not
likely." It said that the DOC was working with another state on an agreement
similar to the California deal. "We are in the process of reviewing a proposal
from that jurisdiction," said DOC Commissioner David Donahue.
November 22, 2006 AP
A state judge decided Wednesday to let California send 2,260 inmates to
Indiana and four other states to relieve prison crowding, though she said the
transfers may be illegal. Two state employee unions "are reasonably likely" to
win their lawsuit against the state next year, but can't prove they are
suffering enough immediate irreparable harm to justify a preliminary injunction
in the meantime, ruled Sacramento Superior Court Judge Gail Ohanesian. Any
damages the unions suffer are more than offset by the "extreme peril" created by
keeping more than 173,000 inmates in space designed for fewer than 100,000,
Ohanesian said.
November 2, 2006 KESP
A Sacramento County judge today rejected state employee unions' attempt to
temporarily block California's plans to move more than two thousand inmates to
other states. But Judge Patrick Marlette set another hearing for later this
month. The judge says that will give the unions another chance to argue that
Governor Schwarzenegger is violating the state Constitution by shipping the
inmates to private prisons in Arizona, Indiana, Oklahoma and Tennessee this
month to relieve crowding in the nation's largest state prison system. The
unions say Schwarzenegger is illegally sidestepping the state's civil service
system and the usual contracting procedures. Schwarzenegger's attorney says the
move is needed to relieve dangerous conditions and the possibility that a judge
could order the early release of inmates.
October 29, 2006 Robinson County Times
Beginning in November, Corrections Corporation of America will begin receiving
up to 1,000 medium-security inmates from the California prison system at its
correctional facilities in Tennessee, Arizona and Oklahoma. The contract is
worth $22.9 million to the Nashville-based prison builder and operator. The
state of California considers it both a bargain — $63 instead of the $90 per
prisoner per day it would cost to keep inmates in their state system — and a
necessity. California Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger declared an emergency in order
to speed up no-bid contracts with CCA and Geo Group Inc. of Florida, another
private prison operator. California has 172,000 inmates crowded into space
designed for 100,000. Adverse reaction began in California, where the prison
workers' unions complained it's cheaper to farm out the convicts only because
the private firms are allowed to pick the inmates they want — meaning those with
fewer discipline and medical problems. The CCA contract is quite advantageous to
the state of California, as well. The inmates will be housed at a CCA facility
in Tennessee for three years with the possibility of two-year extensions. This
is intended to allow California lawmakers time to decide whether to add more
cells, more programs to trim the prison population; or do nothing. In Tennessee,
the focus is on how an influx of out-of-state convicts will interact with
current inmates, and whether the new inmates, if any were to escape, would
behave more ruthlessly in a state that is not their own. But perhaps the
greatest concern echoes past discussions on this page about who is accountable
when a state's prisons are run by a private company. Since the state of
Tennessee is ultimately responsible for the safety of its residents, it's
critical that government officials scrutinize such a large transfer of criminals
who did not pass through Tennessee's legal system. Corporate boardroom
decision-makers should not take precedence over state correctional experts when
safety is involved.
October 27, 2006 Contra Costa Times
Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger's plan to relieve
overcrowding in state prisons by sending thousands of inmates to private,
out-of-state prisons hit an unexpected snag Thursday when a legal opinion
suggested the idea may violate the California constitution. The opinion by the
state's nonpartisan Legislative Counsel could trigger a lawsuit by the state's
powerful prison guards union, which opposes Schwarzenegger's proposal and is
upset with him over its stalled bid for a new contract. "Private profit is the
wrong reason to make decisions about someone's liberty," said Mike Jimenez,
president of the California Correctional Peace Officers Association. Jimenez
added that the union was already assessing whether to file a lawsuit, even
before the legal opinion. California crams about 173,000 inmates into its 33
prisons, roughly double the number the facilities were meant to house. Thousands
sleep in triple bunks or gymnasiums, and officials say space is so tight that
there isn't enough room to provide basic rehabilitation programs. Exporting
inmates is one piece of Schwarzenegger's prison strategy. Earlier this month he
signed contracts with two private prison companies to send 2,260 inmates to
out-of-state facilities. The state expects to begin moving them next month, and
ultimately the governor hopes to send 5,000 inmates out of state, to both
private and public prisons. The opinion released Thursday was written by
attorneys for the Legislative Counsel, the nonpartisan agency that advises the
state Legislature. They concluded that in order for the state to contract with
private entities to provide services, officials must show that the services
"cannot be performed adequately, competently, or satisfactorily by state civil
service employees." The attorneys cautioned, however, that they interpreted the
law generally and did not specifically evaluate Schwarzenegger's proposal.
Senate Majority Leader Gloria Romero, D-Los Angeles, who opposes
Schwarzenegger's private prison plan, asked the counsel to provide a legal
opinion. Administration officials said Thursday afternoon they needed more time
to digest the opinion before commenting. But one corrections official said that
severe overcrowding combined with thousands of prison guard vacancies justify
the private prison contracts. "This is not an action we took lightly," said
Oscar Hidalgo, an assistant secretary for the Department of Corrections and
Rehabilitation. If 5,000 inmates don't volunteer to move out of state,
administration officials have said they will try to force some prisoners to go.
Illegal immigrants and prisoners scheduled to eventually be paroled in other
states would be at the top of the list for involuntary transfers, which would
almost certainly trigger a legal challenge. Paying private companies to house
California inmates is not a new idea. Some 2,800 inmates currently reside in
privately run facilities in California, Hidalgo said, and the state has been
housing inmates in those prisons since the 1980s. "It's stood the test of time,"
Hidalgo said. But Lance Corcoran, a spokesman for the prison guard union, said
no one has ever challenged it in court. That may change soon.
October 26, 2006
A nonpartisan legal opinion requested by Senate Majority Leader Gloria Romero
(D-Los Angeles) has confirmed that state contracts with private prison companies
are unconstitutional. Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger announced last week that
his Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) signed two contracts for
over $153 million to temporarily provide 2,260 beds for California inmates in
other states. The contracts, with The GEO Group Inc. headquartered in Florida
and the Corrections Corporation of America headquartered in Tennessee, follow
the Governor’s October 4 declaration of a state of emergency in California’s
overcrowded prison system. In response to a request by Senator Romero, the
Legislative Counsel issued a seven-page legal opinion declaring “the state would
violate Section 1 of Article VII of the California Constitution by contracting
with private entities for security and public safety services traditionally
performed by [public employees of] the Department of Corrections and
Rehabilitation.” “This legal opinion confirms what I have long believed: that we
should not support prisons for profit,” said Romero, who serves on the Senate
Public Safety Committee and chairs the Senate Select Committee on California’s
Correctional System. “California has a prison overcrowding crisis, and we cannot
privatize our way out of it. This legal opinion brings the responsibility back
on us and reaffirms my call for real reforms that reduce overcrowding while
ensuring public safety. If the Governor wants to call a special session of the
Legislature, he should focus on breaking the cycle of recidivism with parole
reforms and effective rehabilitation programs. “Public prisons are morally and
fiscally accountable to the taxpayers of California. Private prisons are
accountable to their shareholders, with a binding obligation to maximize
profits. If the Governor goes through with these private prison contracts, he
risks exposing the state to costly civil lawsuits. California can’t afford this
mistake. I call on the Governor to do what is ethical and constitutional and
withdraw these contracts immediately.” A hard copy of the Legislative Counsel
opinion is available via fax. Details of the Administration’s October 19
contracts are athttp://www.cdcr.ca.gov/communications/press20061020.html .
October 2006 Duke Magazine
The governor of Florida combines the savvy of a seasoned politician with a
sense of humor that would better befit a junior-high student. No one comes
through Jeb Bush's office in Tallahassee without getting at least a gentle
ribbing; the man likes to joke around. But when he talks about Donna Arduin, his
tone changes, his eyebrows settle, and he begins to celebrate his state and the
fiscal health he wholeheartedly attributes to his former budget manager. "What
state improved to a triple-A bond rating during these tough times? What state
ran an $8.6-billion surplus? She's the budget king." Arduin so effectively
revamped Florida's budget, Bush says, that she made it possible for him to make
good on almost all his campaign promises, cut taxes, and build a surplus, all
despite an economy that continued to lean on tourism even after 9/11 made
Americans reluctant to travel. On Tuesday morning at 5:00, Arduin's mind is
already moving at 100 miles an hour. As if today's presentation wasn't enough
pressure, she sits on the board of Centracore Properties Trust (CPT), a
$200-million company that's just entered crisis mode. The company leases
correctional facilities to operators like the GEO Group Inc., which issued a
statement yesterday that it did not plan to renew its lease with CPT. Investors
interpreted the announcement as a vote of no-confidence, and, by the closing
bell, CPT shares had taken an 11 percent hit. Arduin's pretty sure she knows
what's going on: GEO is trying to sink CPT's stock price so it can gobble up
enough shares to take over the company. By 8:00, she's in the Mercedes, whirring
south, downloading e-mail and answering calls, simultaneously tweaking today's
presentation and coordinating CPT's next move. She gets on the phone with
Jeannie Woodford, California's director of state prisons. "I wanted to see if
you were interested ..." Arduin leads without a drop of desperation. The plan is
to persuade California to lease the prisons directly from CPT, cut out GEO, and
"announce it now," to pump the stock back up before GEO can afford to buy a
controlling share. There's already been a lot of m |