|
Brown County Jail
Brown County, Wisconsin
Aramark
June 14, 2007 Green Bay Press Gazette
The Wisconsin Supreme Court’s decision that Brown County Sheriff Dennis
Kocken doesn’t have the constitutional power to privatize food service at the
jail could cost the county more than $1 million a year. But Bruce Ehlke, the
Madison attorney representing the American Federation of State, County and
Municipal Employees union, said the court’s decision preserves the state
legislature’s authority over county offices such as sheriff, district attorney
and coroner. “A decision in favor of the sheriff would have substantially
impaired the state legislature from having anything to say about county
government,” Ehlke said Thursday. “It’s one thing to blow off a few disgruntled
employees, but there were very significant constitutional issues here.” The
court voted 4-3 that the union could challenge Kocken’s decision to lay off its
workers and enter an agreement with Illinois-based Aramark Correctional Services
to provide the jail’s food service. Kocken said the privatized service saves the
county about $1.1 million a year and allows him to put more officers on the road
and at the jail. Kocken was not available for comment Thursday. A spokesman in
Kocken’s office said questions should be forwarded to attorney Tom Godar in
Madison, who represents Kocken in the case. Godar did not return calls to his
office Thursday. Dean Meyer, executive director of the Badger State Sheriff’s
Association, which backed Kocken with a friend-of-the-court brief, called the
ruling disappointing. Many sheriffs who have privatized meal service at their
jails will have to review it to gauge its impact, he said. “We feel that the
sheriff needs to have the flexibility to run their facility in a cost efficient
manner,” Meyer told The Associated Press. “That’s what the voters put the
sheriff in there for.”
Dane
County Jail
Dane, Wisconsin
Prison Health Services
December 6, 2007 Wisconsin State Journal
Dane County 's new contract for jail health services will cost the county
about $600,000 more a year than its current agreement, but county officials say
mental health services should improve. The proposed $4.4 million-a-year contract
with Nashville-based Correct Care Solutions must win approval from the Dane
County Board tonight before it is sent to Dane County Executive Kathleen Falk
for her signature. Falk 's office said the expiring contract with Prison Health
Services cost about $3.8 million a year. Dane County Sup. Paul Rusk of Madison,
who chairs the County Public Protection and Judiciary Committee, said the new
contract includes staff for mental health services to inmates around the clock.
"That was among my highest priorities -- to have more mental health care
available in the jail, " Rusk said. If approved, CCS will take over Jan. 1 from
Prison Health Services, which has had the contract for the last five years.
According to documents provided by Falk 's office, PHS was paying about 30
full-time equivalent employees to work in the jail. The new contract calls for
almost 39 staff workers, including a full-time mental health director, a
part-time psychiatrist and the equivalent of almost seven social workers.
Contract documents show an average hourly rate of $90 for a medical director,
$92 an hour for a psychiatrist, $69 an hour for a dentist and $40 an hour for a
health services administrator. Dane County Sheriff Dave Mahoney on Tuesday said
CCS did not have the cheapest proposal. "But the company will deliver a level of
service that is better than the current contract provider, " said Mahoney.
December 7, 2006 The Capital Times
Some Dane County Board supervisors are up in arms over a huge, unexpected cost
increase in the health services contract for inmates at the Dane County Jail. At
the same time, county officials are also grappling with costs that have risen by
more than $2 million over the last five years to house inmates in other
counties. Both issues are up for votes tonight. Prison Health Services Inc., the
company contracted to provide health care, is requesting more than $500,000
above what the county has approved for next year's budget. It's a replay of
what's happened in each of the four previous years during which Prison Health
Services has had the jail contract, said County Board Supervisor Paul Rusk,
chair of the Public Protection and Judiciary Committee. The problem is, the
company doesn't come up with its estimated costs for the next year until most of
the current year is over, he said. The contract has averaged between $3.2
million and $3.3 million a year since the company was awarded the contract in
fall 2002. For 2007, however, PHS said it needs $3,886,155 to serve the more
than 1,000 inmates housed in the three county jail facilities. That's the price
the board will vote on tonight in authorizing the 2007 contract with PHS, even
though Rusk's committee has not approved the contract. "I am very upset by this
contract," said Supervisor Bob Salov. "We should put this contract on hold,
extend the status quo for a couple of months and investigate it." Supervisor
Mike Hanson said the board can argue for hours about minor line items in the
budget but will be okaying this half-million dollar expense not budgeted for.
"It's amazing how the board can quibble over $500 for Rhythm and Booms, and then
we're expected to just rubber-stamp a $500,000 item that's clearly needed, but
so late in the game," Hanson said. Sheriff Gary Hamblin said PHS's contractual
cycle always comes after the county budget is approved. "Their increase is tied
to the consumer price index, so they wait until the last quarter before they
make their estimate on how much money they need for the next year," Hamblin
said. "This year is no exception." Regardless of the overage, both Hamblin and
Rusk say they are happy with the work done by PHS. "It's ten times better than
what we had before," Rusk said.
August 9, 2006 Milwaukee Journal Sentinel
Attorney General Peg Lautenschlager's campaign took her opponent, Dane
County Executive Kathleen Falk, to task for taking donations from those pursuing
Dane County business. Lautenschlager's aides said that was inconsistent with
Falk's statements that as attorney general she would not take money from people
subject to enforcement actions by the state Department of Justice.
Lautenschlager's campaign blasted Falk for accepting a $10,000 donation June 27
from the political action committee of Unite Here, a laundry workers union. The
donation came six days after Dane County started an audit of non-union laundry
contractor Superior Health Linens - a company that Unite Here has long
criticized for its labor practices. Lautenschlager's campaign also criticized
Falk for: • Accepting $1,500 from America Service Group Inc.'s political action
committee in 2004 because its subsidiary Prison Health Services has a contract
with the county. • Taking $2,500 from Government Payment Service CEO Dale Conrad
last year because his firm has a county contract allowing people to pay bail
with credit cards. • Receiving money from developers and others who sat on a
committee that Falk convened to advise her on a land-use plan.
February 4, 2005 Capital Times
Dane County Sheriff Gary Hamblin and jailer Mike Plumer won't give a detailed
report on Meng-Ju "Mark" Wu's suicide to the County Board's Public
Protection and Judiciary Committee because a notice of intent to file a claim in
the last jail suicide hasn't been settled.
Following the suicide by inmate Tierra Hill, who hanged herself May 20 in
high-security Cell F of Cell Block 727 in the City-County Building jail, Hamblin
and Plumer gave a detailed report to the committee, trying to give a clearer
picture of the situation before and following Hill's death.
On Sept. 20, the last day of the 120-day window for claims following an
incident, a "notice of circumstances of a claim" with no specific
damages attached was filed with the county by attorney Todd Winstrom of the
Wisconsin Coalition for Advocacy on behalf of Hill's estate, administered by
Minnie Marie Hill, Tierra's mother. According to the
notice, Hill was not given the proper mental health and psychiatric care by jail
staff; the Mental Health Center of Dane County; and Prison Health Services,
medical services contractor for the jail.
April 14, 2004
There are no guarantees that Terrance Griffith, who died in the Dane County Jail
Nov. 17, 2002, would have lived if he had gotten better treatment from jailers
and the private firm that provides medical service in the jail. But there is a
good deal of evidence to suggest that, had Griffith received better care, he
might have lived. And there is a good deal more evidence to suggest that
Griffith was neglected by the people who had a legal and moral responsibility to
ensure that he received basic care. Unable to sleep, vomiting
relentlessly, the 27-year-old man complained of numbness in his legs and blurred
vision. A paraplegic who was suffering from drug withdrawal, he was in deep
distress. Finally, with the last bit of strength he could muster, Griffith
pounded on the steel door of his cell in the segregation unit, begging for
medical care. He was told to shut up. He shook uncontrollably. He
vomited so much that at least one guard admitted the stench from Griffith's cell
was alarming. But after a cursory check, he was left alone in a cell that
stunk of vomit and decay. Then he died. One of the most respected
physicians in Dane County, Dr. Linda Farley, said after reviewing the records of
Griffth's last hours, "He really was neglected." According
to Farley, health care workers at the jail ignored obvious signs that Griffith
was suffering a medical emergency. "The big point is that his physical
condition should have placed him in a hospital situation," said the doctor.
Yet Sheriff Gary Hamblin says "it's simply not true" that Griffith was
neglected. The sheriff claims that an undiagnosed heart condition could have
killed Griffith whether he was in the jail or in a hospital. On that final
point, the sheriff may be right. Then again, he may be wrong. What is beyond
debate, however, is that the failure to move Griffith from the jail to the
hospital has left open the question of whether better treatment would have saved
his life. For Sheriff Hamblin to try to dismiss the evidence that points
to failures on the part of his own staff and the out-of-state health care firm
that provides care in the jail is deeply disappointing. We still think that the
sheriff, who has had the endorsement of this newspaper in every election
campaign that he has run, is a decent and honorable man. But he has fallen into
a bad pattern here. Sheriff Hamblin needs to rethink the unyielding stance
he has taken. Instead of defending actions that seem to be indefensible, the
sheriff should take steps to address the legitimate concerns that have arisen as
a result of Griffith's death. These include: Inviting independent
specialists on health care in jails to review the record and propose reforms.
Examining the contract with Tennessee-based Prison Health Services with an eye
to determining whether private health care services are appropriate in a public
jail. Ensuring that the upcoming county budget process focuses on the need
to develop an infirmary inside, or closely associated with, the jail, which was
built 10 years ago without such a facility. The bottom line should be
clear to all: Sheriff Hamblin can, and must, respond more thoughtfully and
appropriately to the revelations regarding the death of Terrance Griffith.
(Madison.com)
Genesis
Behavioral Services
Sheboygan, Wisconsin
Correctional Medical Services
November 18, 2009 Sheboygan Press
A therapist accused of sexually assaulting two clients was sentenced Tuesday to
two years probation and no jail time after a prosecutor amended eight felonies
to two misdemeanors, citing "proof problems." The amended charges against John
Monacelli mention only one of the alleged victims, a woman identified in court
records as an approximately 40-year-old Milwaukee County resident. Monacelli
admitted having a relationship with the woman while counseling her, saying he
should have ended the relationship and referred her to another counselor. At the
time of the offense — October 2007 — the woman was a resident at Genesis
Behavioral Services in Sheboygan, an in-patient substance abuse rehabilitation
facility where Monacelli was a counselor and interim director. The allegations
are a far cry from the criminal complaint filed in December, which alleged
Monacelli forced the woman and a 29-year-old Sheboygan County man to perform an
array of sex acts and threatened them to keep them quiet. He had been scheduled
for a jury trial next month on eight felony counts of sexual exploitation by a
therapist. "(The amended charges) relate to proof problems and my ethical
obligations as an officer of the court to bring counts I believe I can prove,"
said prosecutor Thomas Storm of the Wisconsin Attorney General's Office. "I
believe this is an accurate reflection of the improprieties, the crimes that
occurred in this situation." Storm said the investigation revealed conflicting
statements from a number of material witness and the alleged victims. Monacelli,
46, of Menomonee Falls, was convicted of two counts of abuse and neglect of
patients and residents, misdemeanors carrying a maximum combined penalty of six
months in jail. Judge James Bolgert, following a joint recommendation by Storm
and Monacelli's attorney, imposed probation and the maximum $2,000 fine. "I
think it's an appropriate response to the charges of which you have been
convicted," Bolgert said. Storm said the alleged victims were told Monday of the
planned amendment, but he said he couldn't say if they supported it. The
original complaint had alleged Monacelli had the two people recount childhood
sexual abuse in great detail and said re-enacting the sexual acts would help
them overcome drug addictions. A civil suit filed by the victims in September
2008 said both were victims of childhood incest and had histories of drug
addiction and mental illness. The civil suit was settled out of court in March,
and the victims' attorney and Knight declined to comment on the terms of the
settlement. The lawsuit — which named Monacelli, Genesis and its parent company,
Correctional Medical Services — had alleged Genesis was negligent in screening
and supervising Monacelli and slow to respond to the allegations of sexual
abuse.
January 5, 2009 Sheboygan Press
A man accused of sexually assaulting several clients while working as
therapist in Sheboygan will make an initial court appearance this afternoon,
online court records show. John R. Monacelli, 45, of Menomonee Falls, is accused
of having sexual contact with a 29-year-old Sheboygan County man and sexual
intercourse with a 39-year-old Milwaukee County woman while working at Genesis
Behavioral Services in October and November 2007. He was charged last week with
eight counts of felony sexual exploitation by a therapist. He is also named in a
civil lawsuit filed by the two alleged victims that claims he made them recount
childhood sexual abuse in great detail and told them the only way to overcome
their drug addictions was to reenact the sex acts with him. The suit, filed in
September, says both victims were residents at Genesis, 503 Wisconsin Ave.,
while Monacelli served as interim director of the residential program. Monacelli
— who was arrested following an investigation by the Wisconsin Department of
Justice — could face up to 60 years in prison, if convicted on all counts. He is
scheduled to appear at 3:30 p.m. before Judge James Bolgert. According to the
criminal complaint: Monacelli exposed himself to the man during a session in
October 2007 about a week after beginning individual counseling sessions with
him at Genesis. The man, who had been assigned to Monacelli, had oral sex with
the therapist at Monacelli’s request. Monacelli repeated the sex acts during
counseling sessions on two other occasions later in October, including one time
when an oral sex act was interrupted by a knock on the door by another Genesis
employee. He told the man to keep the sexual contact a secret. The 39-year-old
woman said Monacelli kissed her and fondled her breasts during an individual
session at Genesis in early October 2007, and the next day he asked her to
perform a sex act before they were interrupted by a knock at the door by another
counselor. The two had sex during a session in mid-October 2007. A few days
later, Monacelli offered to drive her to an appointment in Washington County,
and had her perform another sex act on him on the way back to Sheboygan. Genesis
began an internal investigation of Monacelli’s behavior in November 2007, the
complaint said. The civil suit, which is still pending, was filed in September
in Sheboygan County Circuit Court against Monacelli, Genesis and Madison-based
Correctional Medical Services.
Milwaukee County
Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Wackenhut (Group 4)
March 4, 2009 Journal Sentinel
A firm that is paid more than $1 million annually to provide security for
the Milwaukee County Transit System has its guards spend less than 3% of their
time riding buses, a fraction of the 85% rate called for in its contract.
Instead, most of the bus security officers spent much of their workdays riding
in pairs in vans, patrolling throughout the county, according to a county audit
released Wednesday. "Very little time is spent actually riding buses," the audit
said. Most of those rides were only a few blocks in length. The audit
underscores criticism leveled by Sheriff David A. Clarke Jr. against Wackenhut
Corp., which has provided bus security for Milwaukee County Transit System buses
since 1993. Clarke's complaints that Wackenhut spent too little time on buses
prompted county officials to order the audit a year ago. The audit found that a
separate firm that manages the transit system for the county didn't expect
Wackenhut officers to spend the vast majority of their time riding buses,
despite the contract provision. By consent of Milwaukee County Transit System
officials, the security officers have emphasized patrolling and responding to
calls for help from bus drivers, the audit said. Auditors recommended that
officers should spend more time riding buses and suggested abandoning the
practice of having officers work in pairs. In its formal response to the audit,
transit system officials said it had already begun increasing the number of
hours security officers spent on buses. They now spend about 30% of their
workday riding buses, officials said. Clarke said the figure should be far
higher. "It's a travesty," Clarke said. "The taxpayers aren't getting what they
are paying for." He'll urge transit system officials to have Wackenhut put a
greater emphasis on having officers on buses, particularly from noon to 8 p.m.,
when most fights and assaults happen, the sheriff said. Other security steps are
important, too, such as sending security officers to areas where "large numbers
of students transfer or problems are more likely to occur," said Anita Gulotta-Connelly,
the bus system's managing director. She said the officers also can stay in touch
with many bus drivers by monitoring key intersections. The vehicle patrols by
security officers are important because they permit rapid response to fights or
other incidents on buses, she said in her response to the audit. Transit system
spokeswoman Jackie Janz said consideration would be given to having the officers
work solo. "Our security plan is always evolving," Janz said. System officials
strive to find the right balance in how security resources are deployed, she
said. Cameras logging incidents -- The installation of video cameras on buses
has been an important security improvement, she said. Vivid footage from those
cameras showing assaults on drivers and passengers and aired on local television
also led to the audit request. The audit found 3,216 calls for service by
drivers - anything from fights to snowballs thrown at buses to rousting sleeping
passengers - in 2008. With 1.35 million bus trips and an average busload of 38,
that translates to a 99.76% chance that passengers won't face any problems
riding the bus, the audit said. Other data included in the audit: 100 assaults
on buses last year, the most over the past nine years. It also listed 1,229
disorderly conduct episodes; 24 robberies; 55 thefts; and two sexual assaults
for 2008. The bus drivers union would welcome an increased security presence on
the buses, said Rick Bassler, vice president of Amalgamated Transit Union Local
998. Union wants armed guards -- Union leaders have repeatedly told Wackenhut
executives and transit managers that they want more security officers on the
buses, as well as armed sheriff's deputies and police officers, both uniformed
and undercover, to provide a deterrent, Bassler said. Even Guardian Angels
volunteers in red berets helped in the last year, but drivers prefer sworn law
enforcement officers because "when you've got someone on there with a gun (who)
can arrest people, that's huge," he said. The Sheriff's Department sends the
union reports that show deputies are riding buses every day, often issuing
tickets, following up with schools about problems with student riders and
focusing their efforts on the most troublesome routes, Bassler said. It's not
clear from those reports exactly how much time the Wackenhut officers are
spending on buses, he said. On another security issue, Bassler said bulletproof
shields will soon be installed around drivers' seats on about 25 buses,
something the union has long pressed for. Union representatives will work with
transit managers to determine the routes where the shields can best be used, he
said. Wackenhut was paid $1.13 million last year for a staff of 30. That
includes 20 security officers and 10 managers. The audit found no problems with
the way security officers dealt with minorities or issues of cultural diversity.
County supervisors asked for that review based on some reported problems.
Wackenhut officials didn't return a phone call late Wednesday.
June 4, 2008 WTMJ 620
Four teenagers have been arrested in the beating of a 15 year-old classmate on a
Milwaukee County Transit bus. The Sheriff's Department is still looking for a
fifth suspect. A St. Charles Youth and Family Services student who tried to
start a fight with the victim on May 29th joined four classmates in repeatedly
hitting and kicking him in his head. The victim escaped serious injury by
covering his face. "We obtained surveillance camera video that depicted a
violent mob beating," said Sheriff David Clarke. "It's the kind of incident that
led to the death of Charlie Young, and the incident in which Samuel McClane was
pulled from his car and savagely beaten on West Hampton Avenue, or the
businessman pulled from his car and beaten following Juneteenth Day." "These
gang-style beatings are serious." The four suspects are all 15 or 16 years old
and all have extensive juvenile records for a variety of offenses including
second degree sexual assault, aggravated battery, burglary, possession of
marijuana with intent to deliver, possession of a dangerous weapon in a school
zone, and disorderly conduct. In a press conference Wednesday, Clarke vented his
frustrations with the private security firm contracted to patrol county buses,
St. Charles' students, and Milwaukee's juvenile justice system. "These students
have been a constant problem since the school year started, with over 30
documented instances of causing some sort of disturbance or criminal acts on
county buses," Clarke said. "They are a menace." "I think St. Charles is
responsible for the behavior of their students, including to and from school,"
he added. "They might not see it that way, but I do." "And part of the problem
is that [these suspects'] ages force us to refer them to juvenile authorities,
where they are viewed and treated simply as delinquents and are given probation
and allowed to rejoin civilized society...only to commit further acts even more
appalling than the last." "Juvenile justice in Milwaukee is a broken system."
Clarke called for an immediate revocation of reduced bus fares for St. Charles
students, saying "the County cannot afford the liability of injuries or death
that may occur on these public transportation routes by students from this
facility. If we can't keep them off public transportation, at least they should
have to pay the same fare that law-abiding passengers pay." The Sheriff also
called for a review of Wackenhut Security, which has had a contract with
Milwaukee County for bus patrols since 1992 but does not have officers on the
buses themselves.
February 1, 2008 Trading Markets.com
Milwaukee County Sheriff David A. Clarke Jr. on Thursday blasted the private
security firm hired to guard local buses, questioning whether the $1.1 million
annual cost was worth it. Wackenhut Corp., an international company
headquartered in Florida, has provided security for Milwaukee County Transit
System buses since 1993. Clarke said in a letter to the County Board that the
company had "top-heavy administration that leads to fewer people actually
performing a security function." He called for a county audit of the firm's
contract with the bus system, a move readily agreed to Thursday on a 6-0 vote by
the board's Finance and Audit Committee. Although Clarke is generally a
proponent of privatization to help lower costs of government services, he
faulted the company for a lack of public accountability. Clarke said Wackenhut
had refused to provide detailed information about its bus security operations to
his department. He also said Wackenhut guards spent too little time riding
buses. "If you are going to deal with disorder on the buses, you've got to ride
the buses," he said. Mark Schaefer, general manager of Wackenhut's Milwaukee
operation, declined to comment on Clarke's criticisms. Of Wackenhut's 32
employees working locally on bus security, four are managers, transit system
spokeswoman Jackie Janz said. The firm won the bus security contract in 1993
over other firms that bid, Janz said. The contract was re-bid in 1998 and 2003,
she said. Anita Gulotta-Connelly, managing director of the bus system, praised
Wackenhut, saying the firm last year responded to more than 3,200 security
complaints. "We are very pleased with the level of security they have been able
to provide," she said. Complaints from riders -- Clarke said he's received many
complaints from riders and bus drivers about rowdiness, harassment of riders and
occasional assaults on buses or at bus stops. Clarke assigned deputies from his
tactical unit to help with bus security starting in 2006. He credited the move
with improvements, but said he couldn't back off the deputy coverage without
worrying about a surge in problems. He said Wackenhut security guards often
simply release troublemakers rather than turn them over to local law
enforcement. Clarke said he did not seek the audit because he wanted the
Sheriff's Department to assume Wackenhut's duties and contract revenue. However,
Clarke said: "I wouldn't mind doing it with the proper resources." He said $1
million would only pay for about 15 deputies, far too few for the job.
December 19, 2007 Journal Sentinel
Milwaukee County Sheriff David A. Clarke Jr. has called for an audit of
Wackenhut Corp., claiming the company is doing a poor job despite its nearly $1
million-a-year contract to provide security on county bus routes. Buy a link
hereIn a letter to Milwaukee County Executive Scott Walker and County Board
Chairman Lee Holloway, Clarke asked for a "qualitative and quantitative audit"
to be performed amid questions about Wackenhut's deployment levels. "There has
been little oversight of this program, and self-reporting has allowed Wackenhut
to operate without accountability and in relative anonymity," Clarke wrote in
his letter, dated Tuesday. A copy of the letter was faxed by the Journal
Sentinel to Wackenhut Corp.'s office in Milwaukee, but officials there didn't
immediately comment. Harold Mester, public information manager for the County
Board, said Holloway didn't get a copy of the letter until Wednesday afternoon
and wanted to read further before commenting. Walker could not be reached for
comment Wednesday. Clarke said the county has been contracting with Wackenhut
since 1993 to provide security on bus routes. In January 2006, he said, his
office assigned deputies to Milwaukee County Transit System security due to
rider complaints about disorder and criminal conduct on county buses. Clarke
said his office used its own personnel to restore order with the idea of handing
the services back to Wackenhut. "After nearly two years, we have not been able
to turn this over to Wackenhut," Clarke said in the letter, "not because we
haven't established an acceptable amount of order, but because we fear that we
will have to come back due to Wackenhut's mismanagement." Clarke said his office
attempted to get deployment data from Wackenhut and, after initial resistance,
Wackenhut officials said they didn't retain the data the sheriff's office was
looking for. "They have flat-out stonewalled our effort to obtain data necessary
for us to make deployment decisions with our limited resources," Clarke said in
the letter. A spokesman for Walker said it would be up to county supervisors to
decide whether to order an audit of Wackenhut.
Milwaukee County
Jail
Milwaukee, Wisconsin
TransCor
October 15, 2007 Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel
A Milwaukee County Board committee on Tuesday rejected a plan by Sheriff David
A. Clarke Jr. to privatize inmate transport services with a company in
Nashville, Tenn. Clarke said the job could be done more efficiently, free 15
deputies to work on more intensive law enforcement and save the county $325,000
a year. Supervisors said the move hadn't been well thought out and should not
have been included in County Executive Scott Walker's budget proposal. The
finance committee voted 6-0 to reject the $1.5 million privatization plan, after
the Milwaukee Deputy Sheriffs' Association presented information critical of
TransCor America. The material included news accounts of escapes of prisoners
being transported by TransCor, which bills itself as the largest inmate
transport company in the United States. The association filed a lawsuit last
week to stop the change, arguing that Clarke lacked legal authority to hire an
outside company for prisoner transport. Supervisors questioned whether public
safety would be compromised by using a private company for moving inmates. But
sheriff's Inspector Kevin Carr said, "I don't think the citizens in our county
are going to notice the difference of who picks up the inmates at Waupun (state
prison) and brings them down here to court."
La Crosse County
Jail
La Crosse, Wisconsin
Health Professionals Limited
July 12, 2004
Seventeen-year-old Rosana Hernandez lay on her La Crosse County Jail cot, dizzy
and nauseated as her body went through withdrawal. It wasn't an illegal
drug Hernandez's body craved during her five-day sentence for disorderly
conduct. It was the anti-depressant drugs and iron supplements her doctor had
prescribed for her. Hernandez, who lives in a La Crosse group home, is among a
growing number of jail inmates with mental health and other medical problems who
say they've suffered needlessly because of the jail's new medical staff. The
problems have cropped up in the six months since La Crosse County hired Health
Professionals Limited, a Peoria, Ill.-based provider of medical services to
jails and prisons. Prior to Jan. 1, 2004, county Health Department nurses and a
local doctor ran the jail infirmary. (La Crosse Tribune)
New Lisbon
New Lisbon, Wisconsin
CCA
June 22, 2002
A judge has rejected a claim by a Wisconsin inmate held in an out-of-state
prison that his sentence should be reduced. Dane County Circuit Judge Richard
Callaway ruled that Wisconsin laws on earning good time credit apply to
prisoners housed in other states rather than the laws of the host state. Under
Wisconsin sentencing laws in place at the time, Sept. 15, 2013 would be his
latest discharge date. But Griffin was transferred to the North Fork
Correctional Facility in Sayre, Okla., Jan. 6, 1999. According to his
calculations, if he earned good time credit as an Oklahoma prisoner would, it
would have reduced his sentence by 1,086 days as of the time he filed his suit.
Griffin said a Wisconsin law says inmates housed in "an institution in an
other state are subject to all provisions of law and regulation concerning the
confinement of persons committed for violations of the laws of that state."
The Wisconsin Department of Corrections argued Griffin was misapplying the law
and other sections of state statutes governed parole and reduction of sentences.
The department also argued, and Callaway agreed, that North Fork is not a
"state correctional facility" because it is a private prison owned and
operated by the Corrections Corporation of America. (The Associated Press State
and Local Wire)
June 21, 2002
Wisconsin courts can review the punishment given inmates housed at out-of-state
prisons who are disciplined for infractions at those prisons, a state appeals
court ruled Thursday. The 4th District Court of Appeals ruled that in punishing
seven Wisconsin inmates in 1999, the state Department of Corrections relied
improperly upon findings from a hearing at the Whiteville Correctional Facility,
a private Tennessee prison owned by Corrections Corp. of America. The court said
DOC and the Whiteville prison each violated its own procedures by appointing as
hearing examiner a Whiteville employee who had witnessed the riot that occurred
Nov. 30, 1999. The hearing examiner found seven of them guilty of participating
in the riot, during which about 15 people were taken hostage. DOC recommended
that the seven be transferred to the Supermax Correctional Institution in
Boscobel. Their appeals to Whiteville's warden were denied. They also challenged
their punishment through DOC, which said it couldn't hear their complaints. The
Tennessee courts, on the other hand, said the inmates were residents of
Wisconsin and should file their appeals in Wisconsin. (Wisconsin State Journal)
June 20, 2002
A disciplinary hearing used to punish seven inmates who were allegedly involved
in a disturbance at a private out-of-state prison in Tennessee was invalid
because the hearing examiner witnessed the November 1999 riot, a state appeals
court ruled Thursday. The 4th District Court of Appeals ruled the state
Department of Corrections must hold new administrative hearings to prove the
inmates' involvement in the riot, but state officials cannot consider the
results of the Tennessee hearing. Corrections spokesman Bill Clausius said.
Clausius said the department conducted its own investigation into the
disturbance at the privately run prison in Whiteville when it discovered the
involvement of the hearing examiner, a Tennessee prison official, and found
evidence that a separate group of 19 inmates was involved. During the
disturbance, guards used tear gas to get the inmates to release about 15 people
taken hostage. Three prison employees were injured. Nashville-based Corrections
Corporation of America owns and operates the medium security prison in
Whiteville, which houses about 770 inmates from Wisconsin. (The Associated Press
State and Local wire)
January 2, 2002
A key Republican lawmaker wants to help plug the state's giant budget deficit by
delaying the opening of a 750-bed prison in New Lisbon and smaller correctional
facilities in Oshkosh and Sturtevant. Rep. Scott Walker, R-Wauwatosa,
chairman of the Assembly Corrections Committee, said his proposal to delay
prison opening as well as the hiring of related prison guards and some probation
and parole agents should save $14.5 million. If fewer prison beds open in
Wisconsin, more state inmates will have to stay in private and federal prisons
in Tennessee, Oklahoma and Minnesota. Wisconsin pays $44 a day to keep
each of 3,443 inmates at out-of-state private prisons run by Correction Corp. of
America. That's a cost of about $55.3 million a year. But housing
inmates at Wisconsin prisons costs more. (Wisconsin State Journal)
Outagamie County Jail
Appleton, Wisconsin
Advanced Correctional Healthcare
April 26, 2008 Post-Crescent
The director of the medical group that employs the Outagamie County Jail's
doctor will lead an investigation into an inmate's death, the county's attorney
says. Investigators have asked the county to review the medical evaluation and
treatment of Curtis Heino, a 27-year-old inmate who died of pneumonia Jan. 13.
Advanced Correctional Healthcare, which employs the jail doctor, will lead the
investigation, Joe Guidote, the county's lead attorney, said Friday. Guidote
said he approved a request Wednesday from the Sheriff's Department to have the
medical group's director, Dr. Norman Johnson, conduct the investigation. "We're
as interested as anybody else in making sure that the folks in the jail are safe
from a medical perspective," he said. "We're confident they'll do a
comprehensive evaluation of what happened from a medical standpoint, and we'll
take the results when we get them and give them a close look." Advanced
Correctional Healthcare employs jail doctors, including Dr. George Shotick, who
has worked for the jail since November and signed off on tests of Heino's blood
taken by jail medical staff the week he died. Johnson did not return four
messages left at his office Friday. His home phone number is not listed. Gehring
said earlier this week Shotick would conduct the medical review. Shotick said he
discussed only the autopsy results with the sheriff. They discussed the review
during a conference call late last week, after Gehring faxed the doctor autopsy
results and asked him for his initial impressions of the case, Gehring said
Friday. A Winnebago County investigation cleared the Outagamie jail staff of
negligence but requested an "independent medical professional" review of how the
jail medical staff treated Heino.
Sheboygan County Detention Center
Sheboygan, Wisconsin
Aramark
June 6, 2009 Sheboygan Press
A two-time convicted sex offender is going back to prison after resuming a
sexual relationship with a former Sheboygan County jail worker who was fired for
having sex with him in 2007. The relationship is detailed in the case file of
Wydell J. Vaughn, a 28-year-old Sheboygan man sentenced Thursday to a year in
prison. Vaughn was out of prison for all of three days before authorities
discovered the relationship and put him back behind bars. Court records say
Vaughn met Tammy Green, 37, while incarcerated at the Sheboygan County Detention
Center in 2007. Green, who was married, was a kitchen worker employed by Aramark,
which contracts to provide jail foodservice. Vaughn denied having sexual contact
at the jail, but the two began having sex shortly after his release in August
2007, and Green was later fired for having the relationship, court records show.
The two were found out when Vaughn called Green’s supervisor to complain their
relationship couldn’t move forward since she wouldn’t leave her husband. That
relationship — along with other probation violations such as unapproved contact
with minors and frequenting parks — led to Vaughn being sent to prison for two
years in November 2007. He was released Feb. 24 to a halfway house. Before his
release, Vaughn was repeatedly told he could not have contact with Green, and
all sex offenders must have relationships approved by a probation agent, but he
reestablished contact the day he was released, court records show. Green visited
him at a halfway house that day and the next, then had sex with him on the 26th
when Vaughn was let out to buy clothes for a court appearance on the 27th. A GPS
monitoring bracelet showed the pair drove throughout Sheboygan and also left the
city. Green then went with Vaughn to the court hearing, and the two were seen
kissing in the courthouse hallway, court record show. Vaughn later called his
probation agent from Green’s phone, and Green called the probation agent and
identified herself as his girlfriend after he was arrested for having contact
with her. That arrest came on Feb. 27, three days after he had been released
from prison. He was kept in jail on a probation hold until being sentenced
Thursday by Judge Timothy Van Akkeren. Sheriff Mike Helmke said Green was not a
county employee, though jail administrators have a say in who can work there.
“We conduct a pre-hire background investigation, but other than that the
supervision and employment standards and everything are pretty much regulated by
her employer,” Helmke said, adding that Aramark made the decision to fire Green.
Vaughn was convicted twice in 2002 of felony second-degree sexual assault for
having sex with 14- and 15-year-old girls in 2001, when he was 20. He has served
a total of more than five years in prison in the cases, all but two years of it
resulting from probation violations.
Stanley
Correctional Facility
Chippewa, Wisconsin
Dominion
May 17, 2006 Journal-Sentinel
The Stanley prison that a private company built - and which the state ended up
buying for $87.1 million - violates electrical, plumbing and safety codes that
will cost taxpayers an additional $5 million to repair. The State Building
Commission on Wednesday voted to spend that money to fix a long list of major
problems at the Stanley prison. The vote came after commissioners complained
that buying the prison built by Dominion Asset Services of Edmond, Okla., was a
major mistake. The commission also told the state Department of Corrections to
investigate whether the Oklahoma company can be sued over the code violations.
The prison played a role in the corruption conviction of former state Senate
Majority Leader Chuck Chvala (D-Madison). Dominion executives gave $125,000 to
Independent Citizens for Democracy, a campaign group Chvala illegally controlled
in the summer of 2001, records in Chvala's criminal case show. Chvala changed
his position on the prison and agreed to the state purchase of the facility
after the donations. Chvala was convicted last year of two felonies and is
serving a nine-month sentence on home detention. State officials said they had
no choice but to correct dozens of code violations at the prison, which held
1,511 male inmates last week. "This is the Legislature's fault," said Sen.
Luther Olsen (R-Berlin). "Now, we have to fix it up." Olsen said legislators
should have demanded a discount on the purchase price of the Stanley prison,
since state officials had a strong bargaining position and could have decided
whether or when it opened. "This was a serious mistake, and a boondoggle of the
nth degree," said Sen. Fred Risser (D-Madison). "They sold it to us, and it
didn't meet code." Risser said the Dominion firm "made a nice profit" when the
Legislature and then-Gov. Scott McCallum agreed in 2001 to buy the prison.
Dominion employees also donated $4,000 to McCallum's re-election campaign.
Proper procedures ignored. "We're wasting $5 million on this," said Sen. Carol
Roessler (R-Oshkosh). "This company totally did not follow (code) requirements."
Gov. Jim Doyle, chairman of the Building Commission, said proper procedures were
not followed when the state purchased the prison. As attorney general in 2001,
Doyle had advised legislators that no inmates could be placed in the prison
until it was either leased or bought by the state. The process normally used in
state building projects was circumvented for the Stanley prison, the governor
said, noting that the Legislature and governor must jointly agree on what is
needed, and then the Building Commission must formally approve the plan. The
Stanley fiasco led to new laws prohibiting the speculative construction of
prisons. State government bought the prison in 2002, with the code violations
"not readily observable upon inspection," state officials said. Code problems
that must be corrected include those in heating and cooling systems. Also, the
state must install smoke controls in housing units and electrical grounding
wires, rebuild electric conductors, and move metal stairs. Construction is
expected to start next April and be finished by June 2008. Assistant Milwaukee
County District Attorney David Feiss, who prosecuted Chvala, said he mentioned
at sentencing the $125,000 that Dominion officials gave to the campaign group
the Democratic senator controlled. Told of the code violations, Feiss said, "The
entire transaction is sordid, so it is not surprising that there are details
that were not known then." Calls to Dominion were not returned Wednesday. In
2001, Dominion Asset Services hired several lobbyists to push state purchase of
the Stanley prison through the Legislature. Also lobbying for the purchase were
western Wisconsin legislators and Stanley elected officials. In 2001, according
to state Ethics Board records, those lobbyists included former Senate Majority
Leader Joe Strohl (D-Racine) and former Rep. Rosemary Potter (D-Milwaukee); John
Matthews, former chief of staff to Republican Gov. Tommy G. Thompson; and Ray
Carey, a friend of then-Assembly Speaker Scott Jensen (R-Town of Brookfield).
Jensen pushed for state purchase of the prison during the 2001 legislative
session. Jensen was sentenced to 15 months in prison Tuesday after being
convicted of three felony and one misdemeanor counts of having Assembly workers
campaign on state time.
February 13, 2006 AP
Employees of at least seven companies donated to Gov. Jim Doyle's re-election
campaign around the same time the state picked their firms for no-bid contracts
totaling more than $36.1 million, according to an Associated Press review.
Campaign finance reports show McCallum received $4,001 in 2001 from executives
of an Oklahoma company that built a private prison in Wisconsin hoping the state
would buy it. The money came in one week before the state Building Commission,
chaired by McCallum, approved buying the prison for $75 million.
December 31, 2005 Journal Sentinel
Lobbyist Bill Broydrick testified in 2002 about how Chuck Chvala, the former
Senate majority leader, solicited lobbyists and their clients for contributions.
With Chvala scheduled to begin a nine-month jail sentence on Feb. 13 after
pleading guilty to two felony corruption charges, Broydrick was recently shown a
summary of his then-secret 2002 testimony about how the former Senate majority
leader solicited lobbyists and their clients for contributions. Prosecutors say
another group that got what it wanted was Dominion Asset Services, which built a
prison in Stanley that it was trying to sell to the state. Dominion officials
wrote one check for $50,000 on June 1, 2001, and another for $75,000 on July 1,
2001, to Independent Citizens for Democracy-Issues Inc., court records show. ICD-Issues
was the group Chvala set up to get "soft money" donations from
corporations - companies barred by state law from giving directly to state
candidates and their campaign committees. On July 25, 2001, Chvala and
Republicans brokered a final budget that included $79.9 million to buy the
Stanley prison. Assembly Republicans long supported the purchase of the Stanley
prison, but they were unable to get the deal through the Legislature because of
Chvala's opposition to the deal. "And then, suddenly and surprisingly, he
allowed it to go through," said Rep. Scott Jensen (R-Town of Brookfield),
who was speaker of the Assembly at the time. Dominion built the prison even
though state law bars private companies from operating prisons. The state could
have used the law to negotiate a lower price because only the state and federal
governments could buy the facility, critics said at the time. Jensen defended
the purchase decision, saying it helped move prisoners held out of state closer
to their families while creating jobs in Stanley, near Eau Claire. Around that
time, Dominion employees gave $500 to Jensen and $500 to Rep. Dean Kaufert
(R-Neenah), who offered the budget amendment to purchase the prison. Employees
also gave $4,000 to then-Gov. Scott McCallum, a Republican, and $9,600 to Senate
Democrats. After the state bought the prison, it delayed its opening for almost
a year, after the state determined it would cost more to run the state facility
than to keep inmates in out-of-state facilities.
July 17, 2002
Outraged Stanley Correctional Facility staff and local politicians packed the
dining room of the Renegade restaurant to overflowing Tuesday afternoon.
"It's not just our jobs," said Sgt. Zahn Erdman of Chippewa Falls.
"This is our careers." Erdman has one of the nearly 200 prison
jobs in limbo until the proposed January opening of the facility. It had
been scheduled to open in September with training scheduled to begin this week.
Gov. Scott McCallum accepted a proposal last week by Rep. Scott Suder,
R-Abbotsford, to save the jobs of 77 correctional officers who had been
scheduled to be immediately laid off because of the delay. If the budget
hadn't been approved, the prison might not have opened until 2004, if ever,
McCallum told Suder. Suder showed McCallum and his staff figures
indicating it will cost the state $1.3 million to delay the prison opening until
January. Sen. Dave Zien, R-Eau Claire, said most prisons in Wisconsin are
at 130 percent of capacity. If the Stanley prison were to open, 60
prisoners per week could be taken from the overcrowded prisons and brought into
the Stanley facility. (The News-Herald)
July 9, 2002
The controversial Stanley prison was at the heart of a deal that finally capped
six months of debate over how the state should rid itself of a $1.1 billion
budget deficit. Gov. Scott McCallum and Rep. Scott Suder (R-Abbotsford) struck
the deal, which preserves prison jobs in Suder's area. "The governor and I
had a long conversation about the Stanley prison, and we wound up saving 77 jobs
that were scheduled to be laid off because of the impending delay," Suder
said. "They will be retained at various institutions, including
Stanley." As part of the deal, the hiring of another 108 workers will be
accelerated, Suder said. "Scott proposed a plan that places the Stanley
workers in correctional facilities in the area until the prison opens,"
McCallum said. "I believe his approach is reasonable, and we will make it
work." The budget includes a Democratic Senate proposal that pushed back
the opening of the 1,500-bed facility near Chippewa Falls from Sept. 1 until
Jan. 1. Other costs associated with the prison mount as it awaits inmates. State
taxpayers are spending more than $350,000 a month for salaries, utilities and
payment on the prison. (The Journal Sentinel)
July 5, 2002
State Rep. Scott Suder is hoping to kill a budget provision that would delay the
opening of the Stanley prison in Chippewa County by four months. Suder,
R-Abbotsford, and state Sen. Dave Zien, R-Eau Claire, are pushing Gov. Scott
McCallum to eliminate a state budget provision that would delay the prison's
opening from Sept. 1 until January 2003. Senate Republicans sharply criticized
the delay. Zien said the delayed opening unfairly toyed with the lives of people
already working at the prison and those of people who have been preparing to
start their new jobs. He also said opening the prison would allow the state to
bring back some of the prisoners now housed in out-of-state facilities because
of overcrowding at Wisconsin facilities (The gannet Wisconsin ).
Tomas Cantreras
November 1, 2007 Laredo Morning Times
When Wendolyne Morales received a letter from the Corrections Corporation of
America on Saunders Street, and then spoke with the detainee's wife in
Wisconsin, she knew she was onto something. The KLDO-Univision investigative
reporter spent six months working on a series of 10 stories related to Tomas
Contreras, a resident alien detained at the border for a drug charge and fine he
paid nearly 20 years ago. With the help of photographers Elsa De Leon, Guillermo
Rodriguez, Ruben Carranza and Sammy de la Garza, Morales did stories on the
detainee's plight with the government's mandatory detention law. In particular,
the last one she filed in June, after Contreras was released, propelled her into
the big leagues. This weekend, at a sumptuous gala event in Dallas, her name was
announced after the presenter said, "And the Emmy goes to … " Morales had just
become Laredo's first television reporter to win an Emmy Award. "I feel very
happy and I'm so proud to belong to the team that I do," she said. "More than
anything, it feels good to know that our competitors were the big sharks." Her
entry beat out six other English- and Spanish-language reporters from the
Houston, Dallas and San Antonio television markets in the Lone Star Emmy
category for Specialty Assignment Report-Single News Story. Since the Emmys
opened a chapter in Texas five years ago, this is the first time a KLDO entry
made it into the finals, and the first time that a Laredo television news
network brought home a trophy. A native of Guanajuato, Mexico, Morales came to
Laredo in the seventh-grade and graduated from Cigarroa High School and the
Vidal M. Treviño School of Communications and Fine Arts, where she focused on
television, film and communications. She is pursuing a bachelor's degree in
communications and previously worked for Univision in Corpus Christi. Dressed in
a long, red evening gown that Saturday night, Morales was accompanied by Maria
Montoya, Maria de la Luz de Alba and Alma Blanco. These are her best friends,
"my sisters," she said, describing them as her mentors and role models when they
worked together at another local television station several years ago. "We
grabbed hands and when the announcer said my name, we screamed," Morales said.
"I was so excited and emocionada (emotional) and when I get like that I stumble
my words. I didn't even know what I was saying." What attracted Morales to her
award-winning story was how the mandatory detention laws, enacted immediately
after 9/11, are dividing families and creating undue hardship and suffering, she
said. Meant to catch terrorists at points of entry, the mandatory detention laws
are now detaining people, regardless of their immigration status, for crimes
committed decades ago. "They need to modify the laws because they are punishing
people who went through the whole process to come into the country legally,"
Morales said. "They are detaining people for long periods of time, for six
months or longer," Morales said. "It's dividing families and making people lose
their jobs, because what job is going to wait six months for you to come back?"
In her stories, Morales focused on Contreras, a resident alien and successful
businessman in Wisconsin. He was detained for an 18-year-old drug charge by
Laredo officials at the bridge upon returning from a family vacation in Mexico.
In 1989, Contreras was fined for drug possession when police found cocaine
residue in a car he was borrowing from a friend. Contreras has since built up a
successful career. As part of her series, Morales filmed part of Contreras'
family protesting outside CCA on a cold early Saturday morning, even though she
and the photographer, Guillermo Rodriguez, are off weekends. She also
interviewed Contreras after he was released six months later and learned about
the mistreatment and poor conditions facing detainees behind bars. After she
spoke with his wife in January, Morales said she knew she had to "at least
investigate." She began calling CCA officials and U.S. Customs officials in San
Antonio, and stayed on top of the story. "When we won on Saturday, we were able
to show that Hispanic reporters can also put out an excellent product and can
compete with the big North American chains," she said.
September 24, 2007 Laredo Morning Times
For the first time in history, a television reporter working in Laredo has
been nominated for an Emmy Award. Univision reporter Wendolyne Morales was
recently named a possible recipient of a Lone Star Emmy Award in the Specialty
Assignment Report-Single News Story category. "I was very surprised, but more
than anything I was grateful for the support from God and (Univision General
Manager) Terry Elena Ordaz and (anchor) Osvaldo Corral," Morales said. Morales
said she received tremendous support and encouragement from the Univision team
when she was working on the story of a resident alien, Tomas Contreras.
Contreras was living in Wisconsin but was detained by officials in Laredo when
he crossed the border while returning from a vacation with his family. "He had a
previous drug charge, and was detained under the mandatory detention law,"
Morales said. "He is a successful businessman and a good person. (The
authorities) just wanted to detain him." Morales said Contreras had long since
paid his debt to society, but was detained at the Corrections Corporation of
America detention facility on Saunders Street in east Laredo, nonetheless.
According to the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, Contreras owns five businesses and
was only required to pay a fine after police found cocaine residue in a car
Contreras was driving in 1989. The car belonged to another individual. After
Morales' report, U.S. Rep. Tammy Baldwin, D-Wis. became involved in the matter,
and local news media in Milwaukee also took notice of the issue. Contreras was
freed shortly thereafter. "I am proud of Wendolyne and the entire news team,"
Ordaz said. "This proves that the level of reporting at Univision really reaches
high standards. Maybe now, as a consequence, they may change the laws." Ordaz
said the report came as a result of Morales being well respected and having
confidence in her sources, as do all the reporters at Univision, she said. "Just
to know that we were actually picked, it's wonderful," Ordaz said. Morales has
been at Univision in Laredo for about two years, Ordaz said. The Emmy awards
ceremony takes place Oct. 27 in Dallas.
July 19, 2007 The Capital Times
Tomas Contreras, a Madison businessman held for 81 days earlier this year when
he tried to re-enter the United States, is working to expose the cruelties,
including a two-week stay in an isolation chamber, that he said he was subjected
to at privately run detention centers in Texas. "One night after midnight, I was
sleeping and a whole bunch of people showed up. They tied me up and beat me,"
Contreras, his voice catching, told a forum on immigration issues in Whitewater
last week. Contreras appeared with a "Reality Tour" of the state organized by
Voces de la Frontera -- a rally at the State Capitol in Madison, a forum in
Whitewater, a stop in Milwaukee -- to tell of what he calls abuses in U.S.
Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) detention centers. "Every time I get
into what was going on back there, what happened to these people, it breaks me,"
Contreras said in a recent interview at his family's east side carpet cleaning
business. The experience took 90 pounds off his 260-pound frame, he said, weight
that he's putting back on since he was released following an order by a federal
judge on March 30. Contreras was taken into custody in early January after a
computer check at the border as he and his family were returning from Mexico.
The check turned up a 1989 arrest in Illinois, where a trace of cocaine was
found in the car in which Contreras was riding. He said he paid a $250 fine and
was told he would have no record. Although he has lived legally in the United
States since 1964, Contreras is not a U.S. citizen, so his drug conviction was a
deportable offense under a 1996 law. He has crossed the border without incident
many times since then, but ICE recently upgraded its computers at the border,
which may be why he was detained this time. Tough Texas treatment: Contreras was
held at three ICE facilities in Texas run by private companies under contract
with the federal government. At the Laredo Processing Center in Laredo, run by
Tennessee-based Corrections Corp. of America, a national prison services giant,
Contreras said he was placed in a large dormitory with 80 or more men from
around the world. He saw fights among detainees and unprovoked force used by
guards on detainees. His objections to rough treatment by guards of other
detainees brought threats of retaliation, he said. Contreras launched a hunger
strike and encouraged others to join him in protest of treatment there, as his
wife, Carmen, gave reports on the protest to Spanish-language media. Contreras
said in an interview that he and six other men who challenged guards' treatment
of detainees were shackled and beaten as they were transferred to another
facility. He said after he was awakened in the middle of the night and yanked
from his bunk, his wrists and ankles were shackled to his waist, and he was
prodded repeatedly -- hard -- by a guard wielding a police baton. Because their
shackled feet could not step up high enough to get into a transport van,
Contreras said, he and others we picked up and thrown in. "They tossed us all in
there like animals." Contreras said the incident left bruises on his legs and
arms, and his arms were cut when guards used tools to snap off the plastic
restraints. He was transferred to Corrections Corp.'s Webb County Detention
Center, also in Laredo, where he continued his hunger strike. After a letter
from U.S. Rep. Tammy Baldwin to ICE officials, solicited by Contreras' family,
he said he was transferred to the South Texas Detention Complex in Pearsall, run
by the international GEO Group Inc. After a dispute with a guard about an
assignment to a lower bunk, which Contreras said was made by GEO's medical unit,
he said he was put in a 5-foot-by-6-foot isolation cell. He stayed in the metal
cell, with bunk, toilet and sink, for two weeks, he said. The prescribed periods
of release, for showering, exercise and visits, sometimes were not given because
there weren't enough guards on duty, he added. Steve Owen, Corrections Corp.'s
director of marketing, referred requests for comment to ICE, saying that was
ICE's policy. Nina Pruneda in ICE's public affairs office in San Antonio said
she could find no record in Contreras' file "of the things he said he witnessed
and endured. We are looking into the matter." GEO spokesman Pablo Paez said as a
matter of policy, the company does not comment on "third party allegations" like
those made by Contreras, but said that all of GEO's facilities are run in
accordance with the American Correctional Association's standards for humane
treatment. A spokesperson in Baldwin's office said they had received no further
requests from Contreras since his release, but said Baldwin would ask the House
Committee on Oversight and Government Reform to "investigate issues raised by
the Contreras case in its review of possible civil liberties violations and its
review of the consequences of privatizing basic government services." The
committee, under Chairman Rep. Henry Waxman, D-Calif., is reviewing Bush
administration practices and policies. Waxman's office said that on Baldwin's
request, the committee would look into it. "If she thinks this is an important
issue, the committee will treat it very seriously," Waxman said in a prepared
statement. Contreras said he and six others held in the detention centers are
preparing a federal suit. The San Antonio attorney he said was representing them
did not return calls seeking comment. Contreras said the suit will seek to force
the government to improve conditions at the prison. "I'm not doing it for the
money. I'm doing it so they treat people right," Contreras said. "Somebody has
got to say enough is enough.' "
April 14, 2007 Wisconsin State Journal
I wonder when the U.S. immigration officials realized they made a terrible
mistake by detaining Madison businessman Tom Contreras. Was it when he turned
down special privileges in the for-profit jail run by Corrections Corporation of
America near Laredo, Texas, asking, "What about these other people?" Was it when
he organized a six-day hunger strike against conditions that included
overcrowding and no medical care? Or when the TV crew from Univision, the
Spanish language station, arrived on the scene? Or when the letters started
arriving from U.S. Sens. Herb Kohl and Russ Feingold and from U.S. Rep. Tammy
Baldwin and from regular Madison people who know Tom Contreras as a businessman,
employer and supporter of local charities? Certainly, when Contreras, a legal
U.S. resident since 1964, finally got his day in court on March 30, it took
immigration Judge Bertha Zuniga just a few minutes of reading his file to
realize that a mistake had been made. "She told me she was proud to release me,"
Contreras said. "She told me, 'Go back to your life and keep helping others.'"
Contreras and his wife, Carmen, made it home to Madison on Friday after stopping
by Fort Polk, in Louisiana, to see their son, Tomas, 21. He completed basic
training in the U.S. Army while his father was being detained and is scheduled
to be shipped out to the Middle East. While the family members were traveling,
an official government letter arrived at their home in Madison inviting Tom
Contreras to be fingerprinted as his application to be a U.S. citizen took
another step forward. While his wife and three children are citizens, Tom
Contreras had delayed because of a now-changed Mexican law that forbade
non-Mexican citizens from owning property there. On Saturday, Contreras family
members and their friends gathered in the April sunshine in the side lot of T.C.
Carpet Cleaning on Fair Oaks Avenue. There was the sound of music, the smell of
grilling meat, and the heartwarming sight of Contreras' youngest granddaughter,
Sophia, toddling over and giving Grandpa's leg a big hug. "We want to thank
everyone who supported us," said Contreras' wife, Carmen. She said the family
was overwhelmed with calls and letters of support. "The mayor even sent people
(to the family businesses) to offer help." The family's nightmare began on Jan.
9, when the Contrerases, along with their older granddaughter, were returning to
Madison from visiting family in Mexico. While Contreras estimates he has crossed
the border "a hundred times," a new computer at the border came up with a minor
drug possession ticket from 1989. A federal law passed in 1996, which applies
retroactively, allows the government to deport noncitizens for crimes that
include any drug-related offense. Stories like his were common at the
deportation center. "There was a Cuban who was caught with a joint (of
marijuana) in 1982," Contreras said. "They can't deport Cubans because Cuba
won't accept them. He's been there six months, and he's still there." Others
were being deported to countries they don't remember. "There were people who
have been here all their lives and they're being deported to countries where
they don't even speak the language," he said. Contreras said that conditions
were awful: more than 100 people crowded into a space for 30, only six toilets,
awful food, and non- existent medical care that left "people crying in pain."
"You don't have any rights because supposedly they're going to deport you,
they're never going to see you again, so they know you can't come back and
complain," he said. "And, they make money on you." But, here's the interesting
thing. Tomas Contreras took notes every single day of the 81 days he was in
detention of the abuse he witnessed. He hopes to sit down with the staffs of the
senators who helped him and expose what is going on in the name of homeland
security. As his wife, Carmen, said, they support keeping the borders safe, yet
oppose a system that would distinguish between people who are threats and those
who aren't. Contreras said he can't forget those he left behind in detention: "I
am going back to help the people who are still there."
Waukesha
County Facility
Waukesha, Wisconsin
North Atlantic Extradition Service (formerly run by
TransCor/CCA)
January 21, 2010 TMJ4
Waukesha County's DA has told Today's TMJ-4 the county is ending its
relationship with North Atlantic Extradition. The county's contract expires
within days and it will not be renewed. Guards for North Atlantic were
transporting accused hitman Justin Welch from California to Wisconsin when Welch
escaped earlier this month. Welch has been charged with killing a woman from
Oconomowoc in her home last year. He was caught a day after his escape and has
since been returned to Wisconsin. He is behind bars awaiting trial. North
Atlantic staffers apologized and told Waukesha County the escape was a mistake
and it happened because company policies were not followed. The county's law
enforcement officials say they're planning to review what happened in depth once
a complete investigation is done but for now they do not intend to renew the
prisoner transportation contract with North Atlantic.
January 14, 2010 Press Argus-Courier
A Wisconsin homicide suspect who escaped Wednesday from a transport van in Dora
was recaptured shortly after noon Thursday in Sallisaw. Justin Welch hitched a
ride with a trucker Thursday, and the way he was acting made the driver
"suspicious," Van Buren Lt. Brent Grill said Thursday afternoon. He said the
trucker either called or texted a family member to express concerns, and the
family member alerted Sallisaw police, leading to Welch's capture. Grill said
Welch was currently being held at the Sallisaw Police Department, and he was not
sure if he would be booked into the Sequoyah County Jail or taken elsewhere.
Grill said he was still gathering details, including where Welch spent Wednesday
night after reportedly being seen headed east in a private prison transport van
Wednesday. Grill said the van has not been located yet. Welch was one of five
prisoners being transported by North Atlantic Extraditon Service, a private
transport company from Mississippi. The van stopped at the I-40 rest stop in
Dora so Welch and the other four prisoners could use the restroom. Grill said
Welch stabbed and beat one of the guards, taking his gun and fleeing to the van,
where he struggled with the other, unarmed guard, firing a shot at him but
missing.
January 13, 2010 Press
Argus-Courier
A manhunt is on for a California man accused of murder who escaped Wednesday
morning from a private prison transport van at a rest stop in Dora on Interstate
40. According to the Van Buren Police Department, Justin Welch was being
transported along with four other prisoners when the driver stopped at the I-40
rest area in Dora around 2:45 a.m. The five prisoners were in the bathroom when
Welch is believed to have stabbed the guard in the hand and started beating him
in the head area. Van Buren Lt. Brent Grill said Welch then took the handgun
from the guard and fled from the bathroom to the van, where he confronted the
second, unarmed guard, firing a shot at him in the struggle. Welch then left the
area in the transport van, possibly heading east on the interstate. The van is a
white 2007 Dodge, marked on both sides with the letters NAES, as well as the
words "North Atlantic Extradition Service" Since the transport company is out of
Columbus, Miss., the van has Mississippi license plates LTC537. The guard who
was stabbed was taken to Summit Medical Center, where he was treated and
released. The other guard was not injured.
July 27, 2001
A prisoner transportation company that has been accused of losing and
mistreating inmates allowed the escape of a Wisconsin teen who later made his
way to Texas, where he is charged with attempting to kill a police officer.
Officials at TransCor America Inc. acknowledge their employee botched the case
of the teenage runaway, who wasn't handcuffed when he fled Mitchell
International Airport June 19. The Darien teen stayed on the lam for six
days after escaping from the TransCor guard, stealing two cars in Missouri as he
headed for Mexico, authorities said. He was stopped for not paying for
gasoline at a service station in Texas and, after a high- speed chase, stabbed
an officer in the neck during a struggle, according to police and a criminal
complaint. David R. Puckett, 17, remains jailed on a charge of attempted
capital murder in Hallettsville, Texas. Fault acknowledged "Our
employee did not follow proper procedures in restraining him immediately after
deplaning. He was terminated," said Chuck Goggin, vice president of
TransCor America, which bills itself as the "largest and most
experienced" company in the prisoner transportation industry.
(Milwaukee Journal Sentinel)
Wisconsin
Department of Corrections
CCA
August 4, 2004
The state now has fewer than 500 inmates in out-of-state prisons, but Wisconsin
prisons remain thousands of prisoners over capacity. Thanks for
participating. Please check back for results.Important to bring out-of-state
prisoners back? Do you think it's important for state officials to focus on
bringing out-of-state prisoners back? Yes No State Corrections officials have
been working to bring all prisoners back to Wisconsin by next year. Wisconsin
has 432 prisoners in Minnesota and two in Oklahoma. That's about 1,200 fewer in
out-of-state prisons than four months ago. The state prison system has
22,000 inmates -- about 5,300 over capacity. Corrections officials are
exploring ways to alleviate overcrowding through alternative treatment options
and additional community corrections programs. Gov. Jim Doyle takes credit
for cutting the number of out-of-state prisoners in half since he took office.
Doyle says that Wisconsin does a better job of managing its prison population
and offers many new in-prison treatment programs, such as drug and alcohol
treatment and boot camp-like programs that focus on rehabilitation. (The
Milwaukee Channel)
December 8, 2003
Wisconsin will be able to bring home more than 200 inmates from out-of-state
private prisons in 2004 under agreements with 11 county jails to rent space for
prisoners, state officials said Thursday. Inmates already in Wisconsin
prisons will be moved to the county jails under the agreement to make room for
the 276 out-of-state prisoners who will return to the state. Wisconsin
currently houses 1,986 inmates at prisons in Minnesota and Oklahoma operated by
Corrections Corporation of America. The state Department of Corrections has
relied on the out-of-state prisons for several years to alleviate overcrowding
in Wisconsin prisons. In Minnesota, CCA operates the Prairie Correctional
Facility in Appleton. The corrections department already has contracts
with five of the 11 counties to house about 215 inmates, paying between $51 and
$53 per inmate per day. All of the counties agreed to accept $49.96 per
inmate per day under the new one-year deal, the same the state pays to house
inmates at out-of-state private prisons, corrections spokesman Bill Clausius
said. "The funds that cover the costs of housing these offenders will
stay in Wisconsin," Gov. Jim Doyle said. "Most importantly, the
agreement will improve rehabilitation efforts and ultimately make communities
safer." (AP)
January
31, 2003
Wisconsin
could bring back all but 500 prisoners of nearly
3,500 now being housed in other states by the end of next year, if the state
Department of Corrections was allowed use all its available prison space,
Corrections Secretary Jon Litscher said Tuesday.
Litscher made the comments after the Legislature's budget writing
committee approved a new $56 million-a-year, three-year contract with a private
company to keep up to 5,500 prisoners outside the Wisconsin prison system. Despite concerns voiced by some lawmakers, approving the
contract with Corrections Corporation of America won't further delay openings of
the prisons, Litscher said. An increase in prison population, prompted in part
by Truth-in-Sentencing legislation, means the state still will need
"contract beds," even when all five prisons are operating at capacity,
Litscher said. As of Dec. 6, CCA
had custody of 4,017 Wisconsin prisoners, of whom 3,482 were housed in
Minnesota, Oklahoma and Tennessee under the company's current contract with the
state. Another 535 state prisoners were being housed by CCA in federal prisons
or county jails. "The people
we're employing in Tennessee don't pay taxes here, and they don't spend their
money here," said Sen. Dale Schultz, R-Richland Center. Housing prisoners
out of state appears to be cheaper, based on the $48.50 a day rate the state
will pay CCA next year. But that doesn't consider economic boost from payroll
and other businesses and development associated with operation of the prison,
Schultz said. (La Crosse Tribune)
December
10, 2002
State
corrections officials want a new 3-year contract to house inmates in private
prisons in other states - a controversial idea that would let Gov.-elect Jim
Doyle and legislators keep up to 5,500 prisoners at a time outside Wisconsin
through 2005. In a letter to the Legislature's budget committee,
Corrections Secretary Jon Litscher say the current contract with the CCA ends
Dec. 21. He recommends a 3-year deal at rising costs - including an immediate
10% jump in the daily cost. In the campaign for governor, Doyle repeatedly
said he wanted the number of out-of-state inmates reduced, but offered no plan
to do that. The request for a new contract for out-of-state prison beds
must receive approval from the full Legislature, which does not convene until
January, of the Joint Finance Committee, which is tentatively scheduled to meet
next week. Wisconsin began exporting more inmates than any other state in
1996, when soaring prison populations exceeded the capacity of crowded state
prisons.. (JS Online)
Wisconsin
Legislature
CCA, Dominion
May 17, 2006 Journal-Sentinel
The Stanley prison that a private company built - and which the state ended up
buying for $87.1 million - violates electrical, plumbing and safety codes that
will cost taxpayers an additional $5 million to repair. The State Building
Commission on Wednesday voted to spend that money to fix a long list of major
problems at the Stanley prison. The vote came after commissioners complained
that buying the prison built by Dominion Asset Services of Edmond, Okla., was a
major mistake. The commission also told the state Department of Corrections to
investigate whether the Oklahoma company can be sued over the code violations.
The prison played a role in the corruption conviction of former state Senate
Majority Leader Chuck Chvala (D-Madison). Dominion executives gave $125,000 to
Independent Citizens for Democracy, a campaign group Chvala illegally controlled
in the summer of 2001, records in Chvala's criminal case show. Chvala changed
his position on the prison and agreed to the state purchase of the facility
after the donations. Chvala was convicted last year of two felonies and is
serving a nine-month sentence on home detention. State officials said they had
no choice but to correct dozens of code violations at the prison, which held
1,511 male inmates last week. "This is the Legislature's fault," said Sen.
Luther Olsen (R-Berlin). "Now, we have to fix it up." Olsen said legislators
should have demanded a discount on the purchase price of the Stanley prison,
since state officials had a strong bargaining position and could have decided
whether or when it opened. "This was a serious mistake, and a boondoggle of the
nth degree," said Sen. Fred Risser (D-Madison). "They sold it to us, and it
didn't meet code." Risser said the Dominion firm "made a nice profit" when the
Legislature and then-Gov. Scott McCallum agreed in 2001 to buy the prison.
Dominion employees also donated $4,000 to McCallum's re-election campaign.
Proper procedures ignored. "We're wasting $5 million on this," said Sen. Carol
Roessler (R-Oshkosh). "This company totally did not follow (code) requirements."
Gov. Jim Doyle, chairman of the Building Commission, said proper procedures were
not followed when the state purchased the prison. As attorney general in 2001,
Doyle had advised legislators that no inmates could be placed in the prison
until it was either leased or bought by the state. The process normally used in
state building projects was circumvented for the Stanley prison, the governor
said, noting that the Legislature and governor must jointly agree on what is
needed, and then the Building Commission must formally approve the plan. The
Stanley fiasco led to new laws prohibiting the speculative construction of
prisons. State government bought the prison in 2002, with the code violations
"not readily observable upon inspection," state officials said. Code problems
that must be corrected include those in heating and cooling systems. Also, the
state must install smoke controls in housing units and electrical grounding
wires, rebuild electric conductors, and move metal stairs. Construction is
expected to start next April and be finished by June 2008. Assistant Milwaukee
County District Attorney David Feiss, who prosecuted Chvala, said he mentioned
at sentencing the $125,000 that Dominion officials gave to the campaign group
the Democratic senator controlled. Told of the code violations, Feiss said, "The
entire transaction is sordid, so it is not surprising that there are details
that were not known then." Calls to Dominion were not returned Wednesday. In
2001, Dominion Asset Services hired several lobbyists to push state purchase of
the Stanley prison through the Legislature. Also lobbying for the purchase were
western Wisconsin legislators and Stanley elected officials. In 2001, according
to state Ethics Board records, those lobbyists included former Senate Majority
Leader Joe Strohl (D-Racine) and former Rep. Rosemary Potter (D-Milwaukee); John
Matthews, former chief of staff to Republican Gov. Tommy G. Thompson; and Ray
Carey, a friend of then-Assembly Speaker Scott Jensen (R-Town of Brookfield).
Jensen pushed for state purchase of the prison during the 2001 legislative
session. Jensen was sentenced to 15 months in prison Tuesday after being
convicted of three felony and one misdemeanor counts of having Assembly workers
campaign on state time.
February 13, 2006 AP
Employees of at least seven companies donated to Gov. Jim Doyle's re-election
campaign around the same time the state picked their firms for no-bid contracts
totaling more than $36.1 million, according to an Associated Press review.
Campaign finance reports show McCallum received $4,001 in 2001 from executives
of an Oklahoma company that built a private prison in Wisconsin hoping the state
would buy it. The money came in one week before the state Building Commission,
chaired by McCallum, approved buying the prison for $75 million.
February 2, 2006 Journal-Sentinel
Two former legislative leaders - one of whom is now a state Supreme Court
justice - are prepared to testify that campaigning on state time was widespread
and stretched back until at least the late 1970s, according to summaries of
their testimony filed Thursday in state Rep. Scott Jensen's corruption case. If
a Dane County judge allows the testimony, Supreme Court Justice David Prosser
and lobbyist Joseph Strohl will testify about their time leading the
Legislature. That testimony is intended to benefit Jensen, a Town of Brookfield
Republican who is to go to trial Feb. 21 on felony charges of directing aides to
campaign on state time. "What Jensen is accused of has gone on for many years,"
Strohl said Thursday. "I'm sort of glad that they didn't come after me when I
was there. I didn't realize what we were doing was so improper." Strohl is a
Racine Democrat who served as Senate majority leader from 1986 to 1990. He said
that he would tell jurors that lawmakers routinely solicited campaign cash in
their Capitol offices. He said lawmakers did not accept checks in their offices
and did not discuss donations in connection with bills pending before the
Legislature, which would have been a clear violation of the state's pay-to-play
statute. Dane County District Attorney Brian Blanchard called Strohl's proposed
testimony "misleading . . . confusing and a waste of time" in a brief filed
Thursday that argued against allowing testimony from Strohl and Prosser.
Blanchard's brief echoed a motion he filed last week that says such testimony
would not exonerate Jensen because using state resources to campaign clearly is
a crime. "A claim that 'other guys were doing it' is a confession, not a
defense," Blanchard wrote. Two of Jensen's colleagues, former Majority Leader
Steve Foti (R-Oconomowoc) and Rep. Bonnie Ladwig (R-Racine), recently pleaded
guilty to misdemeanors to avoid trial on directing aides to campaign on state
time. Former Senate Majority Leader Chuck Chvala (D-Madison) and former Sen.
Brian Burke (D-Milwaukee) pleaded guilty last year to felonies for directing
aides to campaign on state time. Burke is now serving a six-month sentence under
home confinement. Chvala will begin a nine-month jail sentence Feb. 13. Jensen's
latest filing came two days after he submitted more than 50 pages of Department
of Justice memos in which Democratic Assembly workers acknowledged widespread
campaigning on state time in the 1998 and 2000 elections. Strohl, the former
Senate majority leader, said in an interview it was "common practice" for
legislators to make fund-raising calls from their Capitol offices. Sometime
between 1988 and 1990, Strohl installed a personal phone line in his office
after Senate Chief Clerk Donald Schneider advised him he shouldn't make
fund-raising calls on a state phone, Strohl said. Strohl is now a lobbyist for
the Menominee Indian tribe, the Corrections Corporation of America, Wellpoint
Inc. and others.
December 31, 2005 Journal Sentinel
Lobbyist Bill Broydrick testified in 2002 about how Chuck Chvala, the former
Senate majority leader, solicited lobbyists and their clients for contributions.
With Chvala scheduled to begin a nine-month jail sentence on Feb. 13 after
pleading guilty to two felony corruption charges, Broydrick was recently shown a
summary of his then-secret 2002 testimony about how the former Senate majority
leader solicited lobbyists and their clients for contributions. Prosecutors say
another group that got what it wanted was Dominion Asset Services, which built a
prison in Stanley that it was trying to sell to the state. Dominion officials
wrote one check for $50,000 on June 1, 2001, and another for $75,000 on July 1,
2001, to Independent Citizens for Democracy-Issues Inc., court records show. ICD-Issues
was the group Chvala set up to get "soft money" donations from
corporations - companies barred by state law from giving directly to state
candidates and their campaign committees. On July 25, 2001, Chvala and
Republicans brokered a final budget that included $79.9 million to buy the
Stanley prison. Assembly Republicans long supported the purchase of the Stanley
prison, but they were unable to get the deal through the Legislature because of
Chvala's opposition to the deal. "And then, suddenly and surprisingly, he
allowed it to go through," said Rep. Scott Jensen (R-Town of Brookfield),
who was speaker of the Assembly at the time. Dominion built the prison even
though state law bars private companies from operating prisons. The state could
have used the law to negotiate a lower price because only the state and federal
governments could buy the facility, critics said at the time. Jensen defended
the purchase decision, saying it helped move prisoners held out of state closer
to their families while creating jobs in Stanley, near Eau Claire. Around that
time, Dominion employees gave $500 to Jensen and $500 to Rep. Dean Kaufert
(R-Neenah), who offered the budget amendment to purchase the prison. Employees
also gave $4,000 to then-Gov. Scott McCallum, a Republican, and $9,600 to Senate
Democrats. After the state bought the prison, it delayed its opening for almost
a year, after the state determined it would cost more to run the state facility
than to keep inmates in out-of-state facilities.
October 17, 2005 WisPolitics.Com
Representative Spencer Black announced today that he is drafting legislation to
ban contributions to state candidates from outside Wisconsin. Black's bill comes
on the heels of press accounts that Governor Jim Doyle raised more than $200,000
in contributions during the first 6 months of this year from people who don't
live in Wisconsin. Previous reports indicate that out of state contributions to
candidates running for state office topped $1.2 million in the last
gubernatorial election year. In addition to statewide candidates, legislators
received hundreds of thousands of dollars from contributors who don't live in
Wisconsin. Major out of state interest givers in recent years have included top
officials in Wal-Mart, the Corrections Corporation of America, petroleum
companies, pay day lenders, and SBC. "When these out of state interests
pour money into Wisconsin elections, they don't care about our state's
well-being. They are out to obtain benefits for themselves. It's time that
Wisconsin elections were cleaned up and stopping out of state contributions is
one way to start doing that," Black concluded.
May 10, 2005 CBS2
Wisconsin's decade-long practice of paying out-of-state prisons to house its
inmates ended last week with the return of 53 inmates from a Minnesota
correctional facility, Gov. Jim Doyle said Tuesday. Doyle said their return
marked a turnaround for a state that once led the nation in the number of
inmates housed outside its borders, peaking at more than 5,000 in the year 2000.
The inmates were held in Oklahoma, Minnesota, Mississippi and Tennessee.
"Our practice of exporting prisoners out has been totally eliminated,"
Doyle said at a news conference. "It doesn't make sense to spend taxpayer
dollars sending prisoners to other states when there is a better chance of
rehabilitation here in Wisconsin."
May 20, 2003
Nearly half of Wisconsin prisoners being held in other states could return to
the state as early as next year under plans to be presented todayby Republicans
revising the 2003-05 state budget. Vacant prisons would open sooner and
existing prisons would boost capacity under proposals to be considered by the
Legislature's Joint Finance Committee, said Sen. Scott Fitzgerald, R-Juneau, who
serves on the committee. Fitzgerald said he also will introduce a budget
amendment to require the state Department of Corrections to contract with county
jails in the state before exporting prisoners. "The emphasis will be
on returning prisoners to the state, which Gov. Doyle has slammed the door on.
We're trying to figure a way to bring as many back as possible at the same
rate," said Fitzgerald, who is ushering Corrections items through the
budget process on behalf of Senate Republicans. The state is expected to
pay about $69 million during the fiscal year that ends June 30 to keep prisoners
in Oklahoma and Minnesota under contract with Corrections Corp. of America (CCA),
said Jere Bauer, analyst with the Legislative Fiscal Bureau. Doyle
supports bringing inmates back to Wisconsin and has proposed $3.4 million in
contract bed savings during the fiscal year that starts July 1, said Doyle
spokesman Dan Leistikow. Savings would come through converting juvenile prison
space to adult use at the Prairie du Chien Correctional Institution and Racine
Youthful Offender Correctional Facility, Leistikow said. But Doyle's plan
also calls for not opening prisons built in New Lisbon and Chippewa Falls until
after mid-2005 as a way to help offset a potential $3.2 billion state budget
deficit. The state pays CCA $48.50 per inmate per day, while the average
daily cost of housing an inmate in a Wisconsin prison was $75.73 in 2001, Bauer
said. Some legislators say the governor's plan, however, fails to consider the
overall economic impact of prisons, including income taxes and spending. That
money should not be sent out of state when prison space is available in
Wisconsin, Fitzgerald said. Republicans will push hard to open the prisons
in New Lisbon and Chippewa Falls and to expand the number of inmates held at
Redgranite Correctional Institution from 750 to as many as 990, Fitzgerald said.
Those changes alone could add 1,400 beds to the state's prison system. The
opening of 1,500-bed Stanley Correctional Institution earlier this year has
helped open prison space in Wisconsin, and budget estimates predict fewer
contract beds will be needed, Bauer said. This year, the state had
estimated it would have to contract to hold an average of 3,739 prisoners per
day through June 30. Doyle's plan would drop that number to 2,415 by mid 2005.
Opening prisons sooner or adding capacity would lower it even further, Bauer
said. (Wisconsin State Journal)
March 4, 2003
About 400 non-violent offenders would be diverted from prison each year under a
program proposed in Gov. Jim Doyle's 2003-05 state budget. The program is
just one of the sweeping changes envisioned in Doyle's two-year $49.4-billion
budget plan, which still must be approved by the Legislature. About 3,000
prisoners would remain in other states as a cost-saving measure. On the
other hand, some Democrats say the state's prison-building boom has been spurred
more by rural economic development needs than sound criminal justice policy. As
of Feb. 14, the state had 3,237 inmates housed in Minnesota, Oklahoma and
Tennessee under a contract with the Corrections Corporation of America, state
records show. The contracts will cost the state about $51 million a year during
the next two-year budget cycle, said Jim Johnson, a budget analyst with the
state Department of Administration. The opening dates of at least five
prisons have been pushed and pulled in a political tug of war between
Republicans and Democrats since the 1,500-bed Stanley prison was built without
state permission by a private company in 1998. In 2001, the state paid about $80
million for the prison, which began accepting inmates in January. Stanley now
houses about 800 prisoners and Doyle has included funding for its operation in
his budget proposal.
July 17, 2002
Just when you think the flow of financial news out of Madison can’t get more
embarrassing, we learn that waiting until September to open the Stanley prison,
one of the proposed fixes in the budget repair bill, will actually cost us $3.5
million more than if the place opened in July, as planned. That doesn’t
include the 78 jobs Gov. Scott McCallum promised he’d save at the prison so
Rep. Scott Suder, R-Abbottsford, who represents the district, would cast the
deciding vote for the budget repair bill. Moving up the opening costs less
because we could bring prisoners home from Tennessee, Minnesota and Oklahoma.
The Legislative Fiscal Bureau did the math in a blunt Feb. 28 memo. “The net
result … is that the delay in opening the Stanley Correctional Institution
(until September) will increase costs $3,475,500.” The bill their leaders
negotiated and the Legislature signed to repair our $1.1 billion budget deficit
would cost us $4.775 million more than opening the prison right now. We’ve
criticized lawmakers for making us dizzy with the spin they’ve spun over this
budget, but maybe we were mistaken. Maybe they just don’t know any better.
(The Post Crescent)
January 31, 2002
The governor may accelerate moving inmates into an empty prison to help make up
for the economic impact a delay in opening the facility could have, his
spokesman said Tuesday. Officials had mentioned a target date of July to open
the prison at Stanley in Chippewa County. Gov. Scott McCallum's budget-cutting
plan would postpone the opening until September as part of a 6 percent budget
reduction for the state Department of Corrections. The governor still wants to
delay the prison's opening but is considering filling the 1,500-bed prison at a
quicker pace once it opens. That would mean providing prison jobs earlier than
expected. (AP)
January 26, 2002
Wisconsin taxpayers are spending about $352,000 a month on a new prison that
stands empty even as state officials ask local governments to tighten their
belts to close a yawning $1 billion budget deficit. The 1,500-bed facility near
Chippewa Falls employs a warden and six other workers - to the tune of $24,500
per month - but they will have no prisoners to watch until at least July, or
possibly September. Meanwhile, Wisconsin continues to spend $4.3 million per
month to house prisoners out of state. The prison, which lawmakers believed
would be a boon to the local economy in Stanley and would allow the state to
bring inmates home, was built by private developers from Oklahoma who speculated
that the state would lease or buy it upon completion. Before that, only the
state had chosen sites and built prisons in Wisconsin. But as long as the
developer, the Dominion Venture Group, met zoning and building codes, it could
legally build the prison. By law, Dominion just could not operate it when
finished. Lawmakers chafed at the developer's chutzpah. Later they objected to
proposed lease-purchase agreements that provided Dominion substantial rent
payments. Finally, it didn't hurt that Dominion lobbied heavily in Madison,
giving some lawmakers and the governor $15,000 in campaign contributions and
spending more than $130,000 on lobbying. Opposition ceased, including the
argument that the state should bide its time, let Dominion's investment sour,
then exercise its power of eminent domain and claim the prison at a bargain
price. McCallum's budget proposal unveiled last week has left Stanley Mayor Dave
Jankoski reeling. Besides delaying the opening of the prison and its economic
impact, McCallum's plan would take away $1 million in shared revenue payments to
his community of 2,100 residents. To eliminate the deficit, McCallum wants to
end aid to cities, towns and villages. "Any delay with this prison is
another frustration," said Jankoski, irritated by paying out-of-state
private prisons money to house Wisconsin inmates. "At times one wonders if
reason doesn't go out the window. Why continue to send this money out of state
when it could be supporting our own Wisconsin workers, who then in turn would
pay taxes in Wisconsin to help them with their tax problem?" Jim Hunter,
Dominion executive vice president, and others at Dominion made $15,000 in
campaign contributions to state officials since 1999, according to state
Elections Board records. McCallum received $4,000, while $9,600 went to
Democrats who control the Senate and for a long time blocked the prison's lease
or purchase. Among eight Senate Democrats receiving Dominion money were Bob
Wirch of Kenosha, $5,000; Kevin Shibilski of Stevens Point, $3,000, and Burke,
$500. Assembly Speaker Scott Jensen (R-Town of Brookfield) and Rep. Dean Kaufert
(R-Neenah), a finance committee member, also received $500 each. "It was
for the purpose of contributing to the political process of our
government," Hunter said with some hesitation when asked about the
donations. "That's the way the system works. Campaigns request
contributions, and we respond." Why money went to certain lawmakers and not
others, Hunter couldn't say. The state is spending about $352,000 per month on
the vacant prison in Stanley. (Milwaukee Journal Sentinel)
January 22, 2002
Faced with a $1.1 billion deficit, the governor Tuesday proposed cutting the
corrections budget $40 million by delaying the opening of seven prison projects,
charging inmates more for their keep and ending the busing of families to
prisons for inmate visits. McCallum's budget adjustment bill would open a
1,500-bed, privately built prison in Stanley in September, two months late
(Milwaukee Journal Sentinel)
|